Passive macromolecular diffusion through nuclear pore complexes (NPCs) is thought to decrease dramatically beyond a 30–60-kD size threshold. Using thousands of independent time-resolved fluorescence microscopy measurements in vivo, we show that the NPC lacks such a firm size threshold; instead, it forms a soft barrier to passive diffusion that intensifies gradually with increasing molecular mass in both the wild-type and mutant strains with various subsets of phenylalanine-glycine (FG) domains and different levels of baseline passive permeability. Brownian dynamics simulations replicate these findings and indicate that the soft barrier results from the highly dynamic FG repeat domains and the diffusing macromolecules mutually constraining and competing for available volume in the interior of the NPC, setting up entropic repulsion forces. We found that FG domains with exceptionally high net charge and low hydropathy near the cytoplasmic end of the central channel contribute more strongly to obstruction of passive diffusion than to facilitated transport, revealing a compartmentalized functional arrangement within the NPC.
The nuclear pore complex (NPC), residing in the nuclear envelope (NE), is the main mediator of transport between the nucleus and the cytoplasm in all eukaryotic cells (Christie et al., 2016; Knockenhauer and Schwartz, 2016; Musser and Grünwald, 2016). It also plays an important part in transcriptional regulation, signal transduction, cell growth, and the cell cycle (Strambio-De-Castillia et al., 2010; Schellhaus et al., 2016). The NPC is one of the largest macromolecular complexes found in eukaryotic cells. It is made of hundreds of copies of broadly conserved proteins, collectively referred to as nucleoporins, or nups. Approximately one third of these are classed as FG nups, because they contain domains with long stretches of repeated phenylalanine-glycine (FG) motifs separated by hydrophilic flexible linkers. FG nups play a key role in forming the selective barrier to transport. Although the NPC is remarkably robust to extensive deletions of FG repeat domains in Saccharomyces cerevisiae (Strawn et al., 2004; Terry and Wente, 2007), alterations to FG nups are associated with many defects, including the onset of numerous types of cancers (Simon and Rout, 2014), as well as with viral infection, in which they might allow undesirable access to the nucleus or compromise the cell’s anti-viral defenses (Simon and Rout, 2014; Mettenleiter, 2016).
Macromolecules traverse the NPC through either facilitated or passive diffusion. Facilitated diffusion is the rapid translocation of cargo-carrying nuclear transport receptors (NTRs) through interactions with FG domains, and it is generally but not necessarily coupled to energy input from the nuclear GTPase Ran (Quimby and Dasso, 2003). Passive diffusion, in contrast, is the equilibration of ions, small molecules, and small- to medium-sized macromolecules between the cytoplasm and the nucleoplasm, independent of NTRs and GTP hydrolysis. FG domains obstruct the passive diffusion of large macromolecules (Paine and Feldherr, 1972; Paine et al., 1975; Keminer and Peters, 1999; Ribbeck and Görlich, 2001; Mohr et al., 2009; Ma et al., 2012), restricting access to the nucleus and contributing to the retention of nuclear and cytoplasmic factors in their appropriate subcellular compartments. Hence, whether a given macromolecule can passively diffuse through the NPC on a physiologically relevant time scale has an important bearing on our understanding of nuclear maintenance and regulation.
A rigid or soft barrier to passive diffusion?
A well-established determinant of passive diffusion rates is molecular mass, which was observed to affect passive permeability in seminal studies by Paine et al. in the 1970s (Paine and Feldherr, 1972; Paine et al., 1975) using state-of-the-art methods for that time, suggesting a molecular mass size threshold of 30–60 kD for permeation of the nucleus. Recent in vitro studies over the last two decades also suggested a relatively sharp threshold of 30–60 kD (Keminer and Peters, 1999; Ribbeck and Görlich, 2001; Mohr et al., 2009; Ma et al., 2012), although such in vitro systems have recently been shown to be quite sensitive to the precise experimental conditions (e.g., the concentration of transport receptors and the nuclear factor Ran; Ma et al., 2012; Lowe et al., 2015). Larger molecules up to 230 kD in size have also been observed to permeate the NPCs in vivo on the time scale of many minutes to hours (Wang and Brattain, 2007; Popken et al., 2015). Nonetheless, the prevailing functional model of passive transport, which we term the “rigid barrier” model, is that of a barrier with a firm size threshold of 40 kD for passive diffusion (Christie et al., 2016; Knockenhauer and Schwartz, 2016; Musser and Grünwald, 2016; Schmidt and Görlich, 2016). According to this prevailing view, the slow permeation of larger macromolecules across the NPC is regarded as residual leakage beyond such a firm threshold (Kirli et al., 2015; Fig. 1 A, red curve). However, this supposed “leakage” may be also interpreted by an alternative “soft barrier” model of transport. In this model, passive transport rates are expected to decrease much more gradually with increasing molecular mass than previously realized (Fig. 1 A, black curve).
Whether the barrier to passive transport is functionally rigid or soft is also closely related to the biophysical mechanism by which the NPC performs its function. Several biophysically inspired models have attempted over the years to explain how the FG domains form the selective barrier to transport, stirring up lively debate in the literature about their biophysical form and behavior (Ribbeck and Görlich, 2002; Rout et al., 2003; Peters, 2005; Lim et al., 2006; Patel et al., 2007; Zilman et al., 2007, 2010; Jovanovic-Talisman et al., 2009; Tetenbaum-Novatt and Rout, 2010; Yamada et al., 2010; Atkinson et al., 2013; Kapinos et al., 2014; Tran et al., 2014; Vovk et al., 2016; Zahn et al., 2016). However, the evidence for these various mechanistic models is generally indirect, because existing experimental technologies are limited in their ability to probe FG repeats within NPCs of living cells at sufficient spatial and temporal resolutions and because of possible differences in the system behavior under in vivo and in vitro conditions. Finally, although many of these models postulate a relatively homogenous distribution of FG repeats in the NPC, it has also been suggested that FG nups in different regions of the NPC may play specific functional roles (Rout and Wente, 1994; Patel et al., 2007; Yamada et al., 2010; Popken et al., 2015). The extent of this functional partitioning and the precise roles of different FG nups remain unclear.
To discern between the rigid barrier and soft barrier functional models, we have used time-resolved fluorescence microscopy that allowed us to quantify the permeability of NPCs to macromolecules of varying molecular sizes, in living S. cerevisiae cells, resulting in a rigorous characterization of the relation between molecular size and passive permeability. We also used theoretical modeling and extensive coarse-grained computer simulations to assess possible biophysical models that could explain our empirical observations. To study the effect of various FG domains on passive transport, we measured changes from wild-type (WT) passive permeability in a set of combinatorially deleted mutant S. cerevisiae strains, in which substantial subsets of FG domains were deleted from the NPC. We compared these measurements to simulations of NPCs with depleted FG domains. Finally, we used statistical data analyses to identify the most prominent features of FG domains that form the barrier to passive permeability.
Quantification of NPC permeability in vivo
To characterize the in vivo function of the NPC as a barrier to passive diffusion of macromolecules, we enhanced our FRAP (Reits and Neefjes, 2001) assay of transport rates of GFP fusion proteins (Timney et al., 2006; Lord et al., 2015), making it substantially more automated and quantitative by integrating several cell biological measurements in a unified pipeline (Fig. 1 B).
In each FRAP experiment, we expressed GFP-labeled substrates in live cells, photobleached the cytoplasmic pool at time t = 0, and measured the nuclear fluorescence over time. As expected of Fick’s law applied to porous membranes (Renkin, 1954), the levels of nuclear fluorescence decayed exponentially over time, following first-order kinetics with a characteristic time constant τ as the labeled substrate equilibrated between the nuclear volume VN and the cytoplasmic volume VC through N NPCs (Fig. 1 B). At the microscopic level, τ is the mean timespan between two consecutive translocation events for a single substrate macromolecule. In bulk, τ is proportional to t1/2, the t1/2 time of nuclear fluorescence levels: τ = t1/2/ln2.
To remove cell-to-cell variability in τ caused by fluctuations in VN, VC, and N, we used our measurements of these morphological features in each individual FRAP experiment to compute the normalized time constant , the hypothetical value of τ in a typical cell with mean values of VN = 4.8 fL, VC = 60 fL, and n = 161 NPCs, as well as the inversely related permeability coefficient p of a single NPC, specified in units of molecules per second per NPC per micromole, equivalent to 1.86 × 10−6 cm/s, as explained in detail in Materials and methods and in Fig. 1 B (Timney et al., 2006; Lord et al., 2015). We repeated each measurement between 13 and 59 times per condition and computed the mean and 95% confidence intervals for both and p.
A gradual and approximately cubic dependence on molecular mass
With this time-resolved FRAP assay, we examined passively diffusing proteins between 27 and 67 kD in mass, spanning the often-cited molecular mass size threshold to passive transport (Fig. 2 A). These substrates each comprised a GFP attached by a short linker to between zero and six repeats of the 7-kD Protein A (PrA) domain and are termed GFP-xPrA in the remainder of this paper (with x denoting the number of PrA repeats). Measurements of permeability coefficients p and normalized time constants were acquired from some 236 WT cells (Fig. 2, C–E; and Video 1), each expressing one of the six differently sized GFP-xPrA substrates.
Passive permeability decreased for substrates with increasing molecular masses, as expected (Fig. 2 E). However, we did not observe any sharp cutoff in leakage at any specific threshold. Rather, we observed a strikingly simple functional relationship, in which increases with molecular mass [proportional to protein volume (Fischer et al., 2004)] to the power of 3.8 ± 1.0 at the 95% confidence intervals (Fig. 3 A). Hence, although the 27-kD GFP equilibrated in a matter of seconds ( = 15 ± 1.4 s), the 67-kD GFP-6PrA substrate equilibrated on the timescale of minutes ( = 413 ± 92 s); a substantially slower rate, yet well within the time scale of biologically relevant processes, including the division time (1.25–2 h) of yeast cells.
Passive transport rates decrease because of reduced translocation efficiency
The increase in the value of for each substrate could be a result of an increasing diffusion time between consecutive substrate encounters with the NPC, a decreased translocation probability per each such encounter (the transport efficiency), or a combination of both. However, the 1.6-fold decrease in the diffusion coefficients in solution from the 27-kD GFP to the 67-kD GFP-PrA (Fig. 2 B) is negligible compared with the 27-fold difference in their values. Therefore, we attribute most of the increase in to changes in the translocation efficiencies of the different substrates.
Approximately cubic dependence extends over a wide range of molecular masses
It was recently illustrated that passive nuclear permeability in yeast is observed on the timescale of hours for substrates with molecular masses of up to 230 kD (Popken et al., 2015), and we were curious whether or not the approximately cubic size dependence extends to these larger substrates. Although our time-resolved FRAP experiments were not practical over time scales >10 min, as cellular growth and new GFP synthesis eventually becomes significant, we could estimate the mean transport time of these larger substrates based on the nuclear to cytoplasmic fluorescence ratio after equilibration reported in that study (Materials and methods). Importantly, our estimates were not scaled in any way to fit our own data and were the result of a straightforward and nonparameterized transformation to estimate the exponential decay rate. We plotted the resulting values against the molecular masses of the combined dataset of 14 substrates ranging in molecular mass from 27 to 230 kD. Strikingly, the same approximately cubic relation that we observed in our own data applies over this combined dataset, and with a much better confidence interval than if we used either of the datasets alone (Fig. 3 B). Because passive diffusion rates may vary for macromolecules of similar molecular mass, we also examined two fusion proteins in which GFP was attached to either one or two domains of the completely unrelated Protein G from Streptococcus (GFP-1PrG and GFP-2PrG), but their passive diffusion rates were consistent with the measurements of similarly sized GFP-xPrA molecules, within 7 kD (Fig. 3, A and B). We conclude that the barrier to passive diffusion lacks any fixed molecular mass threshold and can be predicted remarkably well based on molecular mass within the size range from 27 to 230 kD, at least to first approximation.
Molecular shape has limited effect on passive diffusion
To assess the effects of molecular shape on passive transport rates, we first determined the level of molecular asymmetry for each of the labeled substrates in our 27–67 kD dataset and computed their geometric shapes using three independent methods (Fig. 3 C and Fig. S1 A): (1) analytical centrifugation was used to measure the sedimentation coefficient of each substrate, from which we calculated Smax/S values, which increase with increasing molecular asymmetry (Erickson, 2009); (2) dynamic-light scattering (DLS; Schmitz, 1990) was used to measure diffusion coefficients and the inversely related Stokes radii to provide an independent validation of the measured sedimentation coefficients; and (3) small-angle x-ray scattering (SAXS) was used to most directly compute the shape of the enclosing envelope of each substrate. All three methods were in outstanding agreement with each other (Fig. 3 C). Therefore, we could also rely on the sedimentation coefficients for the 110–230 kD dataset (Popken et al., 2015) to quantify the level of asymmetry of these larger substrates based on their Smax/S values (Fig. 3 D). The shapes of all molecules in the dataset were computed based on either their SAXS envelopes for the smaller substrates or their Smax/S values for the larger ones (Fig. 3 D; and Materials and methods). The GFP-xPrA and -xPrG molecules elongated gradually from 27 to 67 kD with the addition of multiple PrA units, with Smax/S values increasing from 1.15 to 1.35 (Fig. 3, C and D). However, this trend did not persist for the larger substrates up to 230 kD, which had much lower Smax/S values of 1.05–1.10, indicating an estimated 1.5:1 ratio between their long and short axes (Erickson, 2009) and a diameter of ∼10 nm for the 230-kD GFP-5MBP substrate. Hence, the substrates in the combined datasets have a wide variety of shapes, and the smallest and largest substrates are also the most globular. If those shape differences affected passive transport to a significant degree, we would expect that the measured sedimentation coefficient S, which is strongly affected by molecular shape, would be a better predictor of passive transport rates than Smax, the theoretical sedimentation coefficient of a perfect sphere of the same molecular mass (Erickson, 2009), which completely lacks shape information. However, Smax is in fact better correlated with the measured passive diffusion rates than S (Fig. 3 E; and see also Fig. S1 B regarding a similar analysis of the theoretical minimal radius, which also lacks shape information). Hence, the overall molecular mass of a substrate determines its passive diffusion rates, regardless of its particular shape geometry.
Compatibility of a soft barrier with previously proposed models of transport
Several mechanistic models of the transport system assume that large macromolecules are excluded from the NPC due to lack of space. The “aqueous channel” model suggests that passive transport is restricted to a relatively narrow aqueous channel with pore radius r0, with estimates of r0 ranging from 4.4 to 6.1 nm (Keminer and Peters, 1999). Under this assumption, passive diffusion rates are expected to depend on molecular shape more strongly than we observe in this study (Fig. 3 E). Moreover, although the molecules in the combined dataset have different shapes, several of the smallest and largest substrates in the full 27–230-kD range have an exceptionally low Smax/S ratio and can be treated as roughly spherical particles (Fig. 3, C and D). For such particles, the diffusion times through an aqueous pore would increase sharply beyond a well-defined size threshold (Renkin, 1954), which is inconsistent with the data (Fig. 3 F; complete analysis in Materials and methods). The aqueous channel model is also inconsistent with microscopy studies in permeabilized cells (Ma et al., 2012). Similarly, a sievelike hydrogel with a certain characteristic pore size (Ribbeck and Görlich, 2001; Frey and Görlich, 2007; Mohr et al., 2009) or a collection of narrow pores (Mohr et al., 2009; Eibauer et al., 2015) are expected to result in a more well-defined size threshold and be more sensitive to substrate shape, which would affect the likelihood of permeating narrow pores. Other models of passive transport are expected to depend more strongly on molecular mass (i.e., molecular volume; Fischer et al., 2004) than on substrate geometry. Specifically, several models assume a “virtual gate” that depends on entropic exclusion rather than on a geometric constriction (Rout et al., 2000, 2003; Lim et al., 2006; Hough et al., 2015; Sakiyama et al., 2016; Zahn et al., 2016). In such an entropy-driven barrier, substrates with larger molecular mass or volume cause a strain on the system by restricting the conformational freedom of the disordered FG domains that are anchored to the NPC scaffold, resulting in a size-dependent entropic penalty on their passive diffusion.
Comparison to Brownian dynamics simulations of passive diffusion
To test whether our observations can be explained by an entropy-driven model of transport, we simulated the passive transport system using Brownian dynamics simulations (Ermak and McCammon, 1978), as described in detail in the Materials and methods. We modeled the major system components: the NPC, the flexible FG repeats that are anchored to its scaffold, the passively diffusing substrates, the cytoplasmic volume, and the nuclear volume (Fig. 4 A). The chains of FG repeat domains were modeled as flexible strings of beads with each bead representing a single repeat, based on increasing evidence indicating that FG domains are highly disordered, lack secondary structure, and have broad distributions of radii of gyration and end-to-end distances; this representation is consistent with many recent findings (Denning et al., 2003; Lim et al., 2006; Peleg et al., 2011; Hough et al., 2015; Milles et al., 2015; Lemke, 2016; Raveh et al., 2016; Sakiyama et al., 2016; Vovk et al., 2016; Zahn et al., 2016) and the classic entropic spring model of polymers (van der and Maarel, 2008). To gather sufficient statistics about each substrate, we generated 20,000 independent trajectories on a Linux computer cluster (Materials and methods). Video 2 shows a sample simulation trajectory with substrate macromolecules of various molecular masses and their occasional translocation between the cytoplasm and the nucleus.
To directly compare our simulations with the empirical measurements of , we also computed the simulated values for each of the different substrate macromolecules directly from the simulations (Fig. 4 B). We used the microscopic definition of τ as the time interval between consecutive translocations across the NE (Fig. S2, A and B) and normalized this value to account for differences in the cytoplasmic volume, the nuclear volume, and the number of NPCs, as with the empirical values (Materials and methods). As expected of a soft and stochastic filtering mechanism, the interval times between consecutive translocations were widely distributed (Fig. S2 B). Similar to the empirical data, the mean translocation time increased gradually with molecular mass, and remarkably, it could also be approximated by a cubic function of molecular mass, closely resembling the relationship that we observed experimentally after scaling the simulated by a uniform constant factor to account for modeling inaccuracies (Fig. 4 B). Significant changes to the density of FG domains in the NPC (Fig. 4 C), in the cohesiveness of FG domains (Fig. 4 D), or to the dimensions of the NPC itself (Fig. S2 D) had gradual effects on size-dependent filtering in our simulations, with a stronger effect over the baseline levels of passive diffusion rates of all substrates (i.e., the plot is vertically shifted along the y axis) but a much more gradual tuning of the relative size selectivity of different substrates (i.e., the slope of the fitted power functions in Fig. 4, C and D, does not change significantly when plotted in log-log scale). Hence, although cohesive interactions and precise optimizations of the density of FG domains and the pore size could serve to fine-tune the passive barrier, they are not required for recapitulating the fundamental properties of its function. We conclude that a soft barrier to passive transport is consistent with an entropy-driven model of the NPC.
Relating the kinetics and the free energy barrier to passive diffusion
From the spatial density distributions of the different macromolecules in our simulations, we computed their free-energy landscapes as a function of their position along the NPC (Fig. 4, E and F; Materials and methods). As expected, the magnitude of the free-energy barrier (ΔGpassive) increased slowly (sublinearly) with molecular mass (Fig. 4 F). In agreement with transition state theory, the simulated values are exponentially related to ΔG (Fig. S2 C), fitting a slightly modified form of the Eyring-Polanyi equation with R2 = 0.999 (Eyring, 1935). Hence, our simulations suggest that the kinetics of passive diffusion may be modeled as an elementary chemical reaction with a single reaction step and a single transition state.
Measurements in mutant strains reveal disproportionate role for different FG domains
To investigate empirically how the composition of the FG domains that comprise the permeability barrier affects the NPC’s permeability, we have used a comprehensive combinatorial FG domain deletion catalog (Strawn et al., 2004; Terry and Wente, 2007; Adams et al., 2015). We selected a subset of 12 mutant strains that includes truncated FG domains from all 11 yeast FG nups at least once, in various combinations (Fig. 5 A and Table S2). As a positive control for elevated permeability, we used the previously published Δnup170 strain (Shulga et al., 2000). For practicality, we first narrowed our investigation to just the GFP-2PrA and GFP-4PrA substrates, which bracket the often-stated ∼40-kD diffusion limit. For these strains, single-cell FRAP measurements were combined, as before. These permeability measurements of 674 single-cell measurements are summarized in Fig. 5, B and C. Curiously, the permeability of most strains was not greatly increased with respect to either substrate. This includes even the “maximally deleted” mutants, NΔFGCΔFGnsp1ΔFG and NΔFGCΔFGnup100ΔFGnup145ΔFG, which each lack roughly half of the FG mass of the WT NPC (Fig. 5 B; Strawn et al., 2004). In sharp contrast, the nup116ΔFG strain was 2.7–3.8-fold leakier than the WT strain, even though Nup116 is a minimally deleted mutant for which FG repeat domain contributes less than ∼10% of the NPC’s FG mass. Similarly, truncation of the FG domain of Nup100 (a Nup116 paralog), either individually or in combination with other FG nups, resulted in 1.5–2.0-fold increase in permeability to at least one of the substrates (Fig. 5 C). All other strains except the nup49ΔFGnup57ΔFG strain were only 1.0–1.5-fold leakier than the WT strain to either the GFP-2PrA or the GFP-4PrA substrates. Hence, the NPC passive permeability barrier is remarkably resilient to some extensive deletions of FG domains, whereas deletions of certain barrier-forming FG domains, such as those of Nup116 and Nup100 (and to a lesser extent, Nup49 and Nup57) seem to play a disproportionate role on passive permeability.
Deletion of barrier-forming FG domains has a uniform effect on substrates of different sizes
As barrier-forming FG domains are deleted from the NPC, we may expect either that passive permeability would increase more significantly for larger substrates than for smaller substrates or, alternatively, that the deletion of these domains may increase the diffusion rates of both small and large substrates uniformly. To test the effect of FG domain deletion on substrates of different sizes, we chose a subset of four mutant strains that covered truncated FG domains from nine of the FG nups, including Nup116 and Nup100. We collected single-cell FRAP measurements (Fig. 6 A) over the entire set of six labeled substrates (covering the molecular mass range 27–67 for passive diffusion) and for each of these strains. This exploration resulted in 29 substrate–strain combinations, comprising 792 individual cell measurements. Again, the leakiest strains for the full dataset of substrates had either the nup116ΔFG or nup100ΔFG truncations, whereas the basal permeability of the maximally deleted NΔFGCΔFGnsp1ΔFG strain remained statistically indistinguishable from the WT strain (Fig. 6 B). At any rate, deletions had a uniform effect on both small and large substrates compared with the WT strain, regardless of the general level of leakiness; that is, the slope of the fitted power function for each of the strains is attenuated only slightly or not at all in Fig. 6 B (within the statistical confidence intervals), and these slopes describe the extent of size-dependent filtering across substrates of different molecular masses. Notably, this empirical result is again consistent with our simulation model, in which massive deletions of FG repeats had a relatively mild effect on the size-dependent filtering and a stronger effect on their overall basal permeability (compare with changes in slope and in the baseline of the transport times in Fig. 5 F). This observation provides additional support for the model of entropic exclusion from the NPC and suggests that the density of certain FG repeats can be used to fine-tune the passive barrier. This result enables us to more formally define the basal permeability of each mutant strain as a strain-specific multiplier pstrain/pWT relative to the WT, a quantity that applies uniformly to different substrates.
Changes in passive permeability cannot be explained by indirect effects on the transport system
Many factors in the cellular biology of the mutant strains might have influenced our measurements of passive permeability. We first assessed whether passive permeability might be influenced by changes in the following general properties of the transport system: (1) NPC quantities; (2) inefficient targeting of truncated FG nups to the NPC; (3) increased pools of transport receptors at the NPC; and (4) changes in the rates of facilitated transport. We selected key strains that covered a range of phenotypes and FG flavors, in which we tagged key transport receptors and FG nups, to survey for global changes to the quantity or distribution of the machinery of nucleocytoplasmic transport. Namely, these strains were WT, the leaky nup116ΔFG strain, and the massively deleted, nonleaky nsp1ΔFG and NΔFGCΔFGnsp1ΔFG strains. In these strains, we tagged the genomic copy of the transport receptors Kap95-mCherry, Crm1-GFP, Kap123-GFP, and Ntf2-GFP or the nups Nup116-GFP, Ndc1-GFP, and Nup170-GFP and acquired images of the steady-state distributions of each, in all four strains (Fig. S3, bottom). Using assisted automated image analysis, measurements of nuclear, cytoplasmic, and (where possible) nuclear rim fluorescence of 9,621 such cells were obtained. The mean magnitude of change in each measurement, relative to WT, is summarized in Fig. S3. Importantly, we found that most strains changed minimally in their NPC abundance and that therefore these changes did not substantially contribute to our permeability measurements. We also found that Nup116-GFP targets efficiently to the NPC, even when truncated, suggesting that there are not overwhelming changes in NPC stoichiometry in most FG deletion strains. Finally, we found no substantial changes in quantities of fluorescent transport receptors at the nuclear rim in any strain (other than for Ntf2), and by surveying the most abundant transport receptors, we have sampled a significant fraction of facilitated transport.
How facilitated transport has been perturbed in these strains is a matter of particular interest, at least insofar as we can examine in this study, as well as how it contrasts with effects on passive transport. We did observe some changes in the nucleus/cytoplasm (N/C) distributions of soluble transport receptors, illustrating that the cycles of facilitated transport are sensitive to the loss of particular FG domains more than others. Inferring the meaning of some of these changes is beyond the scope of this study, considering the complexity of the system. Nonetheless, it is perhaps unsurprising that the distribution of Ntf2-GFP would be affected by the loss of Nsp1 FG domains, as the interaction between and importance of these two proteins is well characterized (Bayliss et al., 1999, 2002). Interestingly, the strain that showed the most notable effect on facilitated transport of the fluorescent transport receptors was the maximally deleted NΔFGCΔFGnsp1ΔFG strain, in spite of having little effect on passive transport. Though technically more challenging (because of far faster equilibration rates), we therefore examined the dynamic rate of Kap123-GFP exchange between nucleus and cytoplasm, using FRAP, similar to the method we used to assay passive transport. We found that nucleocytoplasmic exchange of Kap123 decreased by 72% in NΔFGCΔFGnsp1ΔFG (Figs. S3 and S4). In strong contrast to the permeability results, exchange of Kap123 decreased only modestly in nup116ΔFG and nsp1ΔFG and had little effect on nuclear rim fluorescence of transport receptors in these strains, even though nup116ΔFG has the largest permeability to passive transport (compare Fig. 6 B). This discrepancy may be a result of loss of docking sites for Kap123, consistent with decreased rim intensity for Kap123 in that strain (Fig. S3) and with recent kinetic models that suggested that facilitated diffusion is rate-limited by the availability of docking sites rather than by transport efficiency (Kim and Elbaum, 2013b). Overall, these results show that different FG nups have a very different effect on passive and facilitated transport, indicating distinct functions for different FG nups in passive versus facilitated transport.
Direct effects on passive permeability as a result of FG nups positions, charge, and hydropathy
Because changes in passive permeability among strains (Figs. 5 and 6) could not be explained by indirect effects such as changes in NPC quantities or the rates of facilitated transport (Figs. S3 and S4), we set out to identify the biochemical and geometrical properties of specific FG domains that might directly affect passive permeability. For each strain, we computed its basal permeability to passive transport relative to the WT strain (pstrain/pWT), averaging over all substrates for which measurements were taken. We then collated an exhaustive list of 33 FG domain features that may affect passive permeability (Table S3). We included such features as the total mass and number of deleted FG domains; sequence features that describe the flavor of deleted FG domains (GLFG/FXFG/other; i.e., their amino acid composition, hydrophobicity levels, fraction of charged residues, and net charge); and geometrical features that describe the approximate spatial localization of different FG nups relative to the cytoplasmic and nuclear end of the NPC, despite progress in mapping the vertebrate NPC (Eibauer et al., 2015; Kosinski et al., 2016), we cannot use these maps because of differences in scale and structure with the yeast NPC (Yang et al., 1998), and so instead, we used our previously reported map, which is at a level of resolution sufficient for the purposes of the current study (Alber et al., 2007b).
From the entire list of 33 features, we were unable to identify a single feature that correlated well with the observed variance in basal permeability among the different mutant strains (Fig. 7 A and Fig. S5). For example, consistent with previous studies (Strawn et al., 2004; Terry and Wente, 2007; Popken et al., 2015), the total FG mass deleted from the NPC did not correlate with the change in passive transport rates (Fig. 7 A). To identify combinations of features that might better explain the observed interstrain variability in basal permeability while minimizing the risk of data overfitting, we used the Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator (LASSO) method for multivariate statistical regression (Tibshirani, 1996), combined with principal component analysis (PCA; Jolliffe, 1982). To offset concerns that the regression analysis may produce a model that overfits the specific data used for training the model, we repeated the regression analysis over a smaller dataset, which included only measurements with the GFP-2PrA and GFP-4PrA constructs. Reassuringly, similar features and weights were selected by the model from the smaller dataset (Fig. S6 A), or when we removed either of the strains with the greatest effect on basal permeability, nup116ΔFG and nup100ΔFG, from the dataset (Fig. S6 B), or lastly, to account for potential uncertainty in the copy number of certain FG nups (Mi et al., 2015), when we assumed a uniform stoichiometry of FG nups at the NPC (Fig. S6 C).
The combined PCA/LASSO model explains the observed variation in basal transport rates between strains with an R2 value of 0.90 (compare Fig. 7 B with the fits of individual features in Fig. S5). Importantly, this statistical regression model has a straightforward and intuitive interpretation, pointing at two groups of features of FG Nups that in combination have the greatest effect on passive transport (Fig. 7 C). The first group consists of positional features of our medium-resolution model of the NPC (Alber et al., 2007b). The second group of features is related to the ratio of net charge to hydropathy score in the FG domains that were deleted from the NPC. Specifically, we conclude from our model that FG domains that are both anchored close to the cytoplasmic end of the NPC (Fig. S7 A) and have a high ratio of net charge to hydropathy (Fig. S7 B) contribute most to the passive barrier, most notably Nup100, Nup116, and possibly the adjacent Nup42, Nup49, and Nup57 (Fig. 7 D).
NPCs facilitate the retention of nuclear and cytoplasmic factors in their appropriate subcellular compartments while tightly regulating their timely exchange. However, the precise relation between the size and shape of macromolecules and their passive translocation rates, as well as the role of different FG nups in establishing the barrier, is still poorly understood. In this study, we provide the most rigorous quantitative characterization of in vivo size-dependent passive diffusion rates to date, based on measurements in both WT and mutant yeast strains (Figs. 1, 2, and 3). Our results clearly support the model of a soft barrier to passive diffusion (Fig. 1 A) and refute the prevailing paradigm of a rather firm barrier at any well-defined size threshold, including the oft-cited 30–60-kD threshold (Keminer and Peters, 1999; Mohr et al., 2009; Ma et al., 2012; Christie et al., 2016; Knockenhauer and Schwartz, 2016; Musser and Grünwald, 2016; Schmidt and Görlich, 2016). Our results provide mechanistic context to recent large-scale screens of nuclear compartmentalization, which indicated that relatively large proteins, larger than the 30–60-kD cutoff, are often equally partitioned between the nucleus and the cytoplasm, similar to smaller proteins (Wühr et al., 2015). Alternatively, such proteins are retained in just one compartment by either binding to even larger molecular complexes, for which passive diffusion is expected to be negligible even if we assume a soft barrier (Wühr et al., 2015) or are actively removed from the other compartment by facilitated diffusion (Kirli et al., 2015). These results indicate that the slow diffusion of much larger substrates across the NPC (Wang and Brattain, 2007; Popken et al., 2015) cannot be interpreted as residual leakage beyond a well-defined cutoff (Kirli et al., 2015) but rather as an intrinsic property of the NPC filtering mechanism.
Suitability of in vivo measurements and labeled probes
Our measurements were performed in live yeast cells, for which we checked for changes in NPC quantity, composition, and potential clogging with soluble transport receptors (Figs. S3 and S4). The measured permeability coefficient of the GFP substrate was 1.1 ± 0.04 molecules/s/NPC/µM (Fig. 2 E), which is comparable to results from in vitro studies of permeabilized HeLa cells (Ribbeck and Görlich, 2001; Mohr et al., 2009; Ma et al., 2012) and NPCs isolated from Xenopus oocytes (Kiskin et al., 2003). However, we prefer the use of in vivo measurements to quantify the operating parameters of the nucleocytoplasmic system, considering that a range of variables in in vitro systems, such as the lack of competition with other transport receptors (Timney et al., 2006; Zilman et al., 2010), RanGTP (Ma et al., 2012, 2016; Lowe et al., 2015), and nonspecific interactions with the cellular milieu (Tetenbaum-Novatt et al., 2012; Hough et al., 2015), were clearly demonstrated to affect the biophysical state of NPCs in general and passive diffusion in particular. These variables have different effects on small and large macromolecules (Lowe et al., 2015) and are therefore likely to introduce a significant bias for characterizing the size threshold for passive diffusion in vitro (Keminer and Peters, 1999; Mohr et al., 2009). The labeled GFP-xPrA substrates are appropriate model substrates for passive diffusion in vivo because PrA and GFP are both understood to be functionally inert in yeast, lack nuclear localization and export signals, and do not interact with native yeast proteins (Gavin et al., 2002; Keilhauer et al., 2015). Moreover, they are more representative of cellular proteins than dextran molecules (Keminer and Peters, 1999), because FG repeats are likely to form weak nonspecific interactions even with mixtures of inert proteins like GFP and PrA (Tetenbaum-Novatt et al., 2012; Hough et al., 2015; Raveh et al., 2016).
Substrate determinants of passive diffusion
Our results indicate that passive diffusion rates depend most strongly on the substrate molecular mass, that is, its volume (Fischer et al., 2004; Fig. 3, A and B), and not so much on molecular shape asymmetry (Fig. 3 E). Various other substrate features have been previously proposed to affect passive diffusion (Naim et al., 2009; Colwell et al., 2010; Tagliazucchi et al., 2013; Goryaynov and Yang, 2014). Indeed, substrates of similar size and shape in our dataset did show relatively small but statistically significant variation in their passive transport rates (compare GFP-xPrA and GFP-xPrG substrates in Fig. 3 A and Table S3). Nonetheless, except in relatively extreme cases (such as the incorporation of many surface hydrophobic residues into diffusion substrates [Naim et al., 2009]), our data suggest that molecular volume is the most prominent determinant of passive diffusion.
Simple biophysical principles underlying size-selective passive diffusion
Several of the proposed mechanistic models of transport posit that passively diffusing substrates are restricted by a well-defined geometric barrier, such as a narrow aqueous pore (Keminer and Peters, 1999) or a sievelike saturated hydrogel (Ribbeck and Görlich, 2001; Frey and Görlich, 2007; Mohr et al., 2009). Therefore, passive diffusion is expected to be sensitive to substrate geometry and plummet at a well-defined size threshold as the substrate reaches the characteristic pore size, which is inconsistent with our data (Fig. 3, E and F). In contrast, if the barrier to passive transport is formed because of entropic exclusion (Rout et al., 2000, 2003; Lim et al., 2006; Sakiyama et al., 2016), the NPC is expected to sense the excluded volume occupied by the substrate, which is a simple function of molecular mass/molecular volume (Fischer et al., 2004) rather than its specific geometry. If passive diffusion depends on overall excluded volume, it is also expected to decay more gradually compared with a geometric barrier. Our simulation results confirm that such a soft virtual gate to passive transport is formed by the anchoring of flexible polymers to a cylindrical pore (Rout et al., 2000, 2003; Fig. 4 and Video 2), in agreement with the overall size-dependent filtering properties of the NPC observed in living cells (Fig. 4 B). Our experimental measurements of passive diffusion in mutant strains are remarkably consistent with our simulation results, showing that the deletion of FG domains may increase the overall leakiness of a given strain, but it affects substrates of different sizes in a similar way, thereby maintaining the relative size selectivity of the NPC (Fig. 6 B). Simply put, the anchored FG domains form a highly crowded environment in the NPC, but because of their disordered and dynamic nature, this environment, the NPC’s central channel, is still permeable to macromolecules. For these macromolecules to pass through the NPC, they must displace these domains, competing for the restricted available volume and restraining the FG domains’ conformations. This generates entropic repulsive forces shaping a free energy barrier to passive diffusion (Fig. 4, E and F); because these forces are caused by displacement, they therefore scale with the volume of the diffusing macromolecules.
Simulations of passive diffusion are robust to changes in the model details
The NPC is a remarkably resilient machine that can withstand extensive deletions and maintain a similar function in a range of divergent eukaryotes. Although the NPCs of different organisms vary in their spatial architecture and in FG nup composition, we incorporated within our model only the basic properties that are sufficient to recapitulate the in vivo properties of the NPC, as observed in all eukaryotes. To avoid bias from uncertain model details, we have attempted to minimize the complexity of our model. Our current model does not attempt to include a high-resolution physical representation of the NPC, but it includes all the major system components that are required to form an entropically driven gate to passive diffusion—namely, a cylindrical pore filled with highly flexible polymers. To verify that this simplification did not skew our results, we tested the resilience of our model over a wide range of model parameters and showed that such changes, including substantial changes to the density of the FG domains (Fig. 4 C), their cohesiveness (Fig. 4 D), and the dimensions of the NPC (Fig. S2 D) had a limited effect on our results. Similarly, competition with transport receptors or the functional arrangement of different types of FG repeats may contribute to modulating this core function (Vovk et al., 2016; Zahn et al., 2016) or contribute to other functions such as facilitated diffusion, but are secondary to this entropic effect in forming the passive barrier itself.
Other approaches have been used to simulate the transport system using a generally higher level of model complexity (Mincer and Simon, 2011; Moussavi-Baygi et al., 2011; Ghavami et al., 2016) than our present simulations. In these studies, passive diffusion rates have been quantified only for a small number of relevant substrate sizes (Mincer and Simon, 2011; Moussavi-Baygi et al., 2011) or they have focused on the system thermodynamics rather than kinetics (Ghavami et al., 2016), prohibiting direct comparisons with our kinetic experimental and computational data. Nonetheless, the free energy barrier to passive diffusion inferred from our simulations increases to the power of 0.67 of molecular mass (Fig. 4 D), which is consistent with the latter thermodynamic study, in spite of different model details (Ghavami et al., 2014, 2016). This robustness to changes in the model details is consistent both with the robustness of the NPC to substantial genetic deletions (Strawn et al., 2004; Terry and Wente, 2007) and with how biomimetic nanopores containing end-grafted FG domains recapitulate major properties of the transport system (Jovanovic-Talisman et al., 2009).
Properties of functional region for passive permeability
Our results indicate that the passive barrier may be mainly formed by a subset of FG nups (Fig. 7 D)—Nup116, Nup100, Nup42, Nup49, and Nup57 (Fig. 7 D)—whereas facilitated transport may be more affected by deletions of another subset of FG nups (Figs. S3 and S4). These results strongly support the concept that the NPC has a higher-level arrangement of particular FG repeats with distinct functionalities distributed by a complex scaffold (Rout and Wente, 1994; Alber et al., 2007b; Patel et al., 2007; Yamada et al., 2010; Tu et al., 2013; Popken et al., 2015). Indeed, truncating both Nup116 and Nup100 together is lethal in yeast (Iovine and Wente, 1997), and these two Nups were suggested to contribute to the passive barrier in the past (Hülsmann et al., 2012; Popken et al., 2015). It has been recently suggested, based on simulation studies, that Nup116, Nup100, Nup42, Nup49, and Nup57 participate in forming a dense region of FG domains within the central channel (Ghavami et al., 2014) and that the truncation of their FG domains may affect the passive transport by disrupting this region, but not the spatial organization and the functions of other FG nups that are projected out of the pore in these simulations (Popken et al., 2015). By applying statistical regression methods to our results, we concluded that the FG nups contributing to passive permeability share two distinct properties: they are colocalized at the cytoplasmic end of the NPC central channel, and they also all exhibit a high ratio of net charge to hydropathy score (Figs. 7, S6, and S7). Interestingly, all of these FG nups are also canonically GLFG nups, which were previously suggested to be functionally distinct from other FG nups (Yamada et al., 2010). However, our results indicate that their position near the cytoplasmic end of the central channel also seems obligatory, as Nup145N, which also carries many GLFG motifs, has little contribution to the passive permeability barrier in our measurements. We note that despite this colocalization at the cytoplasmic end, the effect on entry and exit rates from the nucleus seems to be identical, as the equilibrium ratio between nuclear and cytoplasmic fluorescence levels is insignificant in leaky strains (Fig. S8).
GLFG domains are depleted of charged residues (Patel et al., 2007; Yamada et al., 2010; Adams et al., 2015; Schmidt and Görlich, 2015), yet their overall net charge is in fact strongly positive and their hydropathy score low compared with other FG repeat flavors (i.e., they are overall exceptionally hydrophilic; Fig. S7, B and C). Moreover, although all FG repeats appear to be disordered (Denning et al., 2003; Yamada et al., 2010; Hough et al., 2015), high net charge and low hydropathy are hallmarks of extreme protein disorder (Tcherkasskaya et al., 2003; Dunker et al., 2008; Fig. S4 B). This is surprising because GLFG domains are assumed to be rather sticky and compact compared with other FG domains (Patel et al., 2007; Yamada et al., 2010; Schmidt and Görlich, 2015). It has also been suggested that the high net charge of FG nups may contribute to interaction with the mostly acidic transport receptors (Tagliazucchi et al., 2013), perhaps helping to inhibit passive diffusion through competition. Therefore, the role of highly charged regions at the cytoplasmic end of the NPC in forming the passive barrier needs to be further characterized in future studies; for instance, by mutating charged residues or modulating the hydrophobicity levels of these domains and by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy or SAXS.
Implications of soft barrier on facilitated diffusion
In contrast to the relatively straightforward Eyring-Polanyi relation shown here between and ΔGpassive (Eyring, 1935; Fig. S2 C), accurately relating the energy landscape for diffusing through the NPC to transport kinetics may require more elaborate approaches that account for the increased interaction time of NTRs within the NPC, competition effects, availability of docking sites and differences between import and export (Kopito and Elbaum, 2007; Zilman et al., 2007; Kim and Elbaum, 2013a; Tu et al., 2013). Facilitated diffusion also depends on unique properties of the interactions between NTRs and FG Nups, which were suggested to exchange rapidly (Hough et al., 2015; Milles et al., 2015) through unique interaction mechanisms (Raveh et al., 2016). Nonetheless, if we assume that passive and facilitated diffusion proceed through the same physical conduit, we expect the free energy gain from interactions between NTRs and FG Nups (ΔGinteraction) to roughly counter ΔGpassive. Because the latter increases only slowly (sublinearly) with molecular mass (Fig. 4 F; see also Ghavami et al., 2016), a relatively small number of interactions are expected to facilitate the fast diffusion of relatively large cargo molecules. For example, according to the approximately cubic relation between molecular mass and (Fig. 3 B), we estimate the mean timespan between consecutive passive translocations of 4-MD mRNP complexes (Grünwald and Singer, 2010) to be 107 times slower than for a 27-kD GFP molecule, an energy difference of 12–16 kT according to the Eyring-Polanyi relation (Fig. S2 C; Eyring, 1935). A barrier of this magnitude is not insignificant, but it could be readily overcome by the binding energy from a relatively small number of NTRs. Indeed, 4- to 5-MD mRNP complexes translocate through the NPC in merely 200 ms (Grünwald and Singer, 2010; Lowe et al., 2015), and the facilitated diffusion rates of ∼10-MD complexes of quantum dots and NTRs crossed the NPC within a few seconds when bound to 20 NTR molecules and in less than a second when bound to 40 NTR molecules, respectively (Lowe et al., 2010). These data are consistent with the gradual overcoming of a surmountable energy barrier, as expected from both our empirical and computational results. At the other end of the size spectrum, the rather gradual decrease in the energy barrier with molecular mass also explains why specialized NTRs are used even for some small macromolecules that are transported at high quantities, such as the 25-kD Ran (Smith et al., 1998; Ribbeck and Görlich, 2001), because the energy penalty for passive diffusion scales with the total volume of passive diffusers according to our model.
Understanding how the NPC forms such a soft barrier while facilitating active transport over this wide range of molecular sizes will be advanced significantly by the ongoing structural characterization of the NPC and its FG domains, particularly those within critical locations of the NPC. Additional measurements and simulations that use such refined data will illuminate the functional arrangement of the NPC that enables the cell to maintain the proper flow of nucleocytoplasmic traffic.
Materials and methods
Plasmids were constructed by standard molecular biological methods. DNA constructs were made for expression of eGFP C-terminally tagged with one, two, three, four, or six repeats of the PrA domain from Staphylococcus aureus. These GFP-xPrA genes were subcloned either into the yeast constitutive expression plasmid pYX242 (EMD Millipore, discontinued) or as 6xHIS fusion genes into the bacterial expression plasmid pET28a (EMD Millipore). GFP-1PrG and -2PrG constructs were made similarly, as yeast and bacterial expression constructs, by fusing to GFP either the C2 domain (for GFP-1PrG) or both the C2 and C3 domains (for GFP-2PrG) from Streptococcus protein G (Goward et al., 1990). For details of each plasmid, see Table S1.
FG deletion strains used in this study are derivatives of those described in Strawn et al. (2004) and Terry and Wente (2007). For NPC permeability assays with these strains, their genomic copy of HTB2 was tagged with mCherry. In a subset of these strains, genomic copies of CRM1, KAP95, KAP123, NTF2, NUP116, NDC1, and NUP170 were C-terminally tagged with either GFP(S65T) or mCherry. Genomic tagging cassettes were generated by PCR of either pKT355 (Sheff and Thorn, 2004), in the case of mCherry, or pFA6-GFP(S65T)-HISMX6, for tagging with GFP (Longtine et al., 1998). Details of these strains can be found in Table S2.
For all experiments, yeast strains were grown to early log phase in synthetic complete media containing 2% glucose. For live-cell microscopy, cells were attached to Con A–coated Matek dishes (Zenklusen et al., 2007), in which they were allowed to grow for up to 2 h before preparing a fresh plate.
FRAP assay of NPC permeability
Single yeast cell measurements of permeability were obtained using a substantially more quantitative adaption of a FRAP-based method described by us (Lord et al., 2015).
FRAP experiments were conducted on a DeltaVision deconvolution epifluorescence microscope (Applied Precision Ltd.) fitted with a spot-bleaching laser using a 100× 1.4 NA objective (Olympus). For each assay, a point within the cell was targeted with the bleaching laser, as far from the nucleus as possible. This point was illuminated for 1 s, during which time much of the cytoplasmic pool diffuses through that illuminated area and is bleached, leaving a darkened cytoplasm and a brighter nucleus. Occasionally, a second bleach would be necessary. Over the next 1–10 min, a time course of images of GFP and the Htb2-mCherry nuclear marker were acquired, during which time the visible nuclear and cytoplasmic GFP pools returned to a steady state of approximately equal fluorescence intensities. Subsequently, a stack of GFP and Htb2-mCherry images were acquired in the z axis to obtain the subcellular size and shape measurements necessary for quantitative analysis of the time course.
Images of the 3D image stack were deconvolved for a pseudoconfocal image series, and then the most focused image planes were combined by maximum intensity projection. Nuclear, cytoplasmic, and vacuolar regions were segmented by an automated process based on edge detection of this projection, with these subcellular objects fitted to ellipses. Measurements of nuclear and cytoplasmic volumes and surface areas were obtained from these 2D ellipses by approximating each object as a 3D ellipsoid with a height derived from the mean of the minor and major radii (or just using the minor radii for the height approximation of the cell body, because they tend to sit flat on the slide, like a rugby ball). NPC count of each cell was estimated assuming 11.2 NPCs/µm2 (Winey et al., 1997). More direct 3D rendering of the cells was not possible using this epifluorescence system, because deconvolution algorithms generate artifacts near the top and bottom of the yeast cells, which tend to bend light like small lenses. In spite of the assumptions required in this approach, the morphological values obtained by this method were within 10% of those obtained by direct measurement of a complete 3D rendering using confocal microscopy.
Time course images were processed and segmented using an automated but user-directed software. Images were corrected for flat-field illumination, and then a four-dimensional watershed split was performed to excise the data of the targeted cell. Time course images were segmented into nuclear and cytoplasmic regions using an algorithm based on edge detection of optimized images of the GFP channel (cytoplasm) and the mCherry channel (nucleus). Background-corrected, mean fluorescence pixel intensities of the nucleus and cytoplasm over time were obtained from the segmented regions, normalized to constant total cellular fluorescence to correct for photobleaching during image acquisition. As we were using a nonconfocal imaging system, cytoplasmic pixel measurements excluded the area near to the brighter nucleus to minimize the effect of out-of-focus light. Conversely, nuclear measurements have negligible effect from cytoplasmic light intrusion, which is considerably darker than the nucleus during the most important part of the time course (and thus contributes very little signal). Note that for the reverse experiment, in which the nucleus is bleached, it is technically more challenging to target the smaller nucleus, and the nuclear pixel measurements are more affected by light haze from the bright surrounding cytoplasm.
Data integration for computing NPC permeability coefficients
In the experiments, we directly measured the nuclear fluorescence over time, the volume of the cytoplasm and the nucleus, and the surface area of the NE. We show how these measurements can be combined to compute the permeability coefficient particular to each strain–substrate pair in units of molecules per second per NPC per micromole (or 1.86 × 10−6 cm/s; explained below in this section). In the analysis, we assumed that the diffusion of GFP-xPrA within the nucleus and cytoplasm is rapid, compared with its exchange across the NE, and that the rates of mass transport across the envelope follow Fick’s first law. This approach is similar to that described by Peters and colleagues for their ex vivo single-channel experiments (Keminer and Peters, 1999; Kiskin et al., 2003). The first assumption is supported by the empirical observation that equilibration times in each compartment are less than a second, whereas equilibration across the membrane is approximately several seconds to minutes. The second assumption is validated by the decay in nuclear fluorescence following single exponential kinetics in the FRAP experiments.
Based on these assumptions, the flux of GFP (J) at any time, namely the net amount of substance flowing from the nucleus to the cytoplasm through NPCs per time unit per membrane surface area unit, is simply related to the nuclear (N) and cytoplasmic (C) concentrations of GFP by Fick’s first law applied to porous membranes:
where C and N are given in micromoles, p is a coefficient of permeability for the NE given in units of molecules per second per NPC per micromole, particular to this strain and reporter. Note that these units are equivalent to 1.86 × 10−6 cm/s, using the fact that NPCs are regularly spaced throughout the NE at a conveniently constant density of 11.2 NPCs/µm2 surface area throughout the cell cycle (Winey et al., 1997), consistently so among strains according to measurements of rim intensity of nups (Fig. S3). We favor the use of molecules per second per NPC per micromole because these units are more intuitive in the context of the current study. The flux J, in molecules per second per NPC per micromole, can be also stated in terms of the net change in N over time t in seconds, the nuclear volume Vn in liters, and the Avogadro constant Na, specified in µM−1:
The cytoplasmic concentration C can be eliminated entirely if we assume that each cell has a constant amount of GFP substrate, T, and use the cytoplasmic volume Vc.
After some simple rearrangements:
This solution for the resulting simple ordinary differential equation (ODE) for N over time (t) is:
Time course traces of nuclear GFP fluorescence (Nf) were therefore fitted to a single exponential,
The time constant of exponential decay τ is the inverse of b, whereas p can be derived from τ, which we measure directly, provided morphological measurements of the cell, thus:
We note that p is independent of the morphological measurements of the cell, which were only used to compute it from the raw measurements of τ. Thus, p is derived as the permeability of a particular strain’s NPCs toward a particular GFP-xPrA variant, in units of net molecules diffusing through a single NPC per second per 1 μM concentration differential across the NPC. For each strain–substrate condition, 14–58 single-cell measurements were made, and the mean value stated ± SEM. All image processing and analyses were handled by MatLab scripts, coordinated by custom graphical user interfaces, which facilitated the evaluation and refinement of multidimensional image segmentation, side-by-side with the resultant fluorescence traces and derived measurements.
Similar measurements of the dynamics of Kap123-GFP were taken using this FRAP method. These measurements also fit well to the basic form of the same single exponential relationship, as expected (Kopito and Elbaum, 2007; Kim and Elbaum, 2013b). However, in this case, the value of the exponential time constant τ includes the transport of Kap123 alone and in an unknown quantity of cargo and/or NTR complexes, each for which the time constant may be dominated by docking probabilities to the NPC rather than transport efficiency (Kim and Elbaum, 2013b).
Estimation of transport time constant for proteins in the Popken et al. dataset
Popken et al. (2015) reported the ratio of nuclear to cytoplasmic fluorescence of inert reporter macromolecules after 3 h of expression and 1 h of equilibration. By assuming exponential decay of the normalized cytoplasmic pool (as observed in all of our FRAP experiments) and that their yeast cells had similar mean NPC counts, cytoplasmic volumes, and nuclear volumes to our own, we estimated the transport time constant (the exponential decay coefficient) that would lead to the same nuclear to cytoplasmic fluorescence ratio within an hour. We were able to apply this analysis only to the bulkier macromolecules in the size range 109–230 kD, which transport slowly enough to prevent full equilibration within this time scale.
Sedimentation constant measurement by sucrose gradient ultracentrifugation
WT yeast, expressing each of the GFP-xPrA substrates were harvested then lysed by cryogenic grinding. Cell lysates were clarified by low- and then medium-speed centrifugation, first at 14,000 rpm in a benchtop mini-centrifuge for 15 min and then at 55,000 rpm in a benchtop ultracentrifuge in a TLA55 rotor (Beckman Coulter) for 30 min. Lysates for all substrates were combined, and then 100 µl combined lysate was overlaid on 5–15 or 5–20% sucrose gradients. Overlaid on the same gradients was a commercial mixture of low molecular mass globular protein standards, containing 100–200 µg each protein standards, RNase, albumin, ovalbumin, and chymotrypsinogen A. Sucrose gradients were centrifuged for 19–24 h in an SW55 rotor (Beckman Coulter) at 55,000 rpm. Gradients were unloaded into 1.5-mm fractions using a piston gradient fractionator. All methods were performed at 4°C in solutions buffered with transport buffer with Tween (20 mM Hepes, pH 7.4, 110 mM KOAc, 0.1% Tween-20, and 2 mM MgCl2) spiked with a 1:200 mixture of both a commercial protease inhibitor cocktail (Sigma-Aldrich) and Solution P (0.5 mg/ml Pepstatin A and 20 mg/ml PMSF, in ethanol). Morris buffer concentrate (6×) was added to the gradient fractions for separation by SDS-PAGE. One set of gels was Western blotted and then probed with anti-GFP (Roche), whereas another set of gels was stained with Coomassie to detect the protein standards. Relative quantities and migration profiles of the GFP-xPrA substrates and the globular standard proteins were measured from images of the Western blots or Coomassie-stained gels, respectively. Sedimentation coefficients were calculated from the peak migration distance of each protein using standard calculations (Griffith, 1983). Stated sedimentation values are a mean of three to six such experiments. S values of GFP-xPrA are compared with those of the globular commercial standards in Fig. S1 A.
Diffusion constant measurement by DLS
Recombinant GFP-xPrA fusion proteins were expressed as HIS-tagged versions from pET28 plasmids in BL21-DE3 Escherichia coli. Cells were lysed using a microfluidizer, clarified by centrifugation, and the fusion proteins were purified from the lysate via their 6xHIS tags with TALON resin using standard protein purification methods. Purifications were performed in PBS in the presence of 0.1 mM EDTA and a protease inhibitor cocktail. Diffusion constants of 1-mg/ml samples of the recombinantly purified fusion proteins were measured using a DLS instrument (Wyatt Technology) using the manufacturer’s Dynamics software. Reported values are the averages of 5–10 measurements.
SAXS profiles of five constructs of GFP-PrAs and two constructs of GFP-PrGs (Fig. 3 D and Table S4) were collected at concentrations ranging from 0.5 to 2.0 mg/ml at temperatures of 15°C (beamline 4–2 of the Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Lightsource, SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory). All purified, His-tagged SAXS samples were prepared as for the DLS experiments and directly dialyzed overnight at 4°C against 20 mM Hepes, 300 mM NaCl, and 5% glycerol buffer. The 5% glycerol protects proteins from radiation damage during x-ray exposure (Kuwamoto et al., 2004). Up to 20 1-s exposures at SSRL beamline 4–2 were used for each sample. The SAXS profile of each buffer was obtained in the same manner and subtracted from a protein SAXS profile. The buffer subtracted SAXS profiles were initially analyzed using the ATSAS package (Petoukhov et al., 2012) to calculate radius of gyration (Rg) and maximum particle size (Dmax; Table S4). The mean of the smaller scattering angle regions (q < 0.15 Å-1) of the lower concentration profiles (∼0.5 mg/ml) and the mean of the wider scattering angle regions (q > 0.12 Å-1) of the higher concentration (∼2.0 mg/ml) profiles were merged to obtain the final experimental SAXS profiles.
Shape modeling based on SAXS and ultracentrifugation data
The ab initio shape of each of the substrates in our dataset of GFP-PrA macromolecules (Fig. 3 D, substrates ≤68 kD) were generated from their corresponding SAXS profiles by running DAMMIF (Franke and Svergun, 2009) 20 times and then refined through an additional 40 DAMMIN (Svergun, 1999) runs followed by superposition and averaging with DAMAVER (Volkov and Svergun, 2003). Because Smax/S were highly correlated with the shape asymmetry measured by SAXS (Fig. 3 C, top) and consistent with diffusion coefficient measurements by DLS (Fig. 3 D, bottom), we modeled the shapes for the larger substrates in the Popken et al. (2015) dataset based on their Smax/S ratios (Fig. 3 D). For illustration purposes, the crystallographic models of GFP (accession no. 1EMA), PrA (accession no. 1ZXG), PrA (accession no. 1GB1), and maltose binding protein (accession no. 1ANF) subunits were fitted to the enclosing envelopes.
Comparison of aqueous channel model to experimental measurements
The empirically tested theory of diffusion through porous aqueous membranes predicts that the permeability coefficient p of porous membranes depends on the particle probability to enter the pore (Eq. 3) multiplied by the particle friction with the pore walls (Eq. 4; Renkin, 1954):
and p = F1 · F2, where r is the particle radius and r0 is the pore radius. We show that this model of a narrow aqueous channel results in a rigid rather than soft barrier to passive transport that is incompatible with the data (Fig. 3 F; using the approximation for globular proteins [Erickson, 2009]). More formally, when r << r0, then and so F2 dominates p, and in this case, it is easy to show by taking the first derivative of F2 that p decreases extremely slowly with respect to either radius or molecular mass. In particular, in this radius range, it decreases more slowly than the cubic relation observed experimentally (Fig. 3 F). Conversely, as r/r0 reaches 1.0, p is dominated by F1, which sharply drops to zero at that limit, as can be shown by taking the derivative of F1. Specifically, it cannot be approximated by an inverse-cubic relation between p and the molecular mass, except over an extremely narrow range of radii or molecular masses: the derivative of an inverse-cubic function takes the value −3 on a log-log scale, so we can take the derivative of ln(F1) with respect to ln(MW) and compare to −3, again assuming :
Eq. 5 takes the value −3 ± 0.5 (approximately cubic) only when r/r0 is between 79 and 84%, or stated in terms of molecular masses, when MM/MM0 is between 49 and 59% of MM0, the molecular mass of a spherical molecule of radius r0. Hence, a simple aqueous pore model cannot be used to approximate the cubic relation that we observed over the wide range 27 to 230 kD, or for that matter, with any other soft gradually decaying (long-tailed) size-dependent barrier (compare Fig. 1 A and Fig. 3 F). We conclude that passive transport cannot correspond to a translocation through a simple aqueous channel that obeys the classic models of porous membranes and that a more elaborate model is needed to explain the observed transport rates.
Brownian dynamics simulations
We modeled the transport system using our open-source Integrative Modeling Platform package (http://integrativemodeling.org; Russel et al., 2012). The simulation model consists of the NE, the NPC, and the diffusing substrates, all enclosed within a bounding box of 100 × 100 × 100 nm (Fig. 4 A). The NPC central channel was modeled as a 15-nm–high cylinder with the inner diameter of 27 nm, forming a cavity within the NE (control simulations on a slightly larger NPC that better reflects the known NPC geometry are described at the end of this section). 32 chains of FG repeats were anchored to the NPC scaffold in 4 layers of 8 chains each. Each chain was modeled as a flexible string of 45 beads of radius 0.6 nm each (Fig. 4 A, inset). Consecutive beads were connected an equilibrium length of 1.8 nm between consecutive bead centers and using a linear potential, approximating the springlike nature of flexible polymers in general (van der and Maarel, 2008) and FG repeat domains in particular (Denning et al., 2003; Lim et al., 2006; Hough et al., 2015; Milles et al., 2015; Lemke, 2016; Raveh et al., 2016; Sakiyama et al., 2016), but using a constant force of 1.0 kcal/M/A as a first approximation. Substrate molecules were modeled as rigid spheres of molecular masses from 28 to 223 (radii of 2.0 to 4.0 nm, assuming constant protein density of 1.38 g/cm2; Fig. 4 A, inset). 100 substrate molecules were included, resulting in the substrate concentration of ∼0.2 mM. Excluded volume interactions were approximated using a constant repulsive force of 20.0 kcal/M/A, which was exerted on overlapping spheres or on spheres that penetrated either the NE or the bounding box. To approximate the differences in the diffusion rates of molecules of different sizes, we assume for simplicity that the Stokes radius of each sphere equals its actual radius R in angstroms and assign each sphere a translational diffusion coefficient using the Stokes-Einstein equation:
in A2/fs units, where η = 0.92 is the dynamic viscosity of water at 297.15 K in mPa*s units and kT is given in femtojoules. Brownian dynamics simulations were implemented in Integrative Modeling Platform (Russel et al., 2012) in standard form (Ermak and McCammon, 1978) at 297.15 K. The force vector acting on the i’th particle at time step t is computed from the gradient of the energy function. The particle coordinates Xi are then updated using the discrete integration equation:
where is a normally distributed random variable with zero mean and variance . Hydrodynamic interactions were neglected.
The dynamics of the entire system were simulated for 20.0 µs with a time step of 470 fs. The first 10.0 µs of each simulation were considered as equilibration time and discarded from the subsequent statistical analysis. The entire process was repeated 20,000 times independently. By collecting statistics from each of the 100 copies of each substrate type, we obtained data from 10.0 s of simulation per particle type using a total computation time of ∼9,000 central processing unit days on our local Linux computer cluster. The simulations with modified FG repeat densities were conducted as described in the first paragraph of this section, but the number of chains of FG repeats was decreased to either 28, 24, 20, or 16 chains, arranged in four layers as before. Control simulations were also performed on a larger system that more closely approximates the known dimensions of the yeast NPC and the NE (Yang et al., 1998; Alber et al., 2007a; inner diameter of 38 nm and NE width of 30 nm), with seven layers of eight chains of FG repeats each to maintain the same grafting density. These control simulations produced the same overall trends as those of the smaller systems (Fig. S2 D). Another control simulation used an eightfold larger box size (8.7-fold larger cytoplasmic and nuclear volumes) to verify that we model the effect of changes in these volumes correctly, resulting in a ninefold decrease in simulated transport rates. The smaller systems were used for the rest of the analysis to obtain better-converged statistics. Control simulations of cohesive FG domains were conducted by introducing a binding site on a random surface point on each of the FG beads with an attractive range of 6 Å and an attractive force constant of 2.5 kcal/M/Å (potential binding energy of 15 kcal/M per site), acting between pairs of FG beads. Each bead was also assigned a random rotational diffusion coefficient using the Einstein-Stokes equation. Torques between binding sites were integrated similarly to the integration of translational forces described earlier in this section for Xi(t + 1). The configuration files for all simulations are available at https://zenodo.org/record/154746#.V-WW-pMrJE6.
τ is the exponential time constant in seconds for the measured decay in nuclear fluorescence after photobleaching in individual cells. At the single-molecule level, τ is the mean timespan between two consecutive translocations through the NE. τ is a function of p, the cytoplasmic volume Vc, the nuclear volume Vn, and the number of NPCs in the cell:
where Na is Avogadro’s number in µmol−1 (Materials and methods). is the hypothetical value of τ in a typical yeast cell with mean values of cytoplasmic volume, nuclear volume, and NE surface area. p is the permeability coefficient of the NE in molecules per second per NPC per micromole (flux per concentration difference), or equivalently, 1.86 × 10−6 cm/s, assuming a density of 11.2 NPCs/µm2; p is inversely proportional to . ΔGpassive is the free energy penalty for the translocation of an inert macromolecule from the cytoplasm or the nucleus into the NPC.
Computation of free energy landscape from the simulations
The positional distribution of the simulated particles was computed over a 100 × 100 × 100 grid with voxel size of 1 × 1 × 1 nm in time intervals of 10 ns over all simulations. The 2D energy landscape (Fig. 5 E) spanned by the z axis (projected position along the NPC central axis) and the x axis (arbitrary direction on the orthogonal plane parallel with the NE) was computed by averaging over all planes that lie on the central axis of the NPC and transformed to an energy landscape with units of kT based on the Boltzmann distribution by taking the log of these densities. Similarly, the energy landscape across the NPC (Fig. 5 F) was computed by obtaining the marginal distribution along the z axis (integrating over the x and y coordinates; Fig. 5 F).
Transport factor and nup distribution analysis
The steady-state distributions of genomically tagged Kap95-mCherry, Kap123-GFP, Ntf2-GFP, Crm1-GFP, Nup116-GFP, Nup170-GFP, and Ndc1-GFP were observed in each of the representative yeast strains, nup116ΔFG, nsp1ΔFG, NΔFG CΔFG nsp1ΔFG, and WT. All images for each fluorescently tagged protein were acquired on the same day for each strain to avoid daily fluctuations in fluorescence measurements. For each combination of fusion protein and strain, images of fields of live cells were acquired at 100× magnification on an Axiovert 200 microscope (ZEISS) fitted with an UltraView spinning disk confocal imaging head (PerkinElmer), using an iXon EMCCD camera (Andor Technology), controlled by MetaMorph imaging software. A series of images through the complete z axis of each field was acquired.
Semiautomated image analysis was performed using a series of image segmentation, measurement and data-review scripts, and graphical user interfaces created in MatLab for this expressed purpose. Each image was corrected for flat field illumination, background subtracted, and then all images in the z axis were collapsed by maximum projection down to a single image for each field of cells. Using image segmentation scripts, cell bodies were detected and then segmented into nuclear, cytoplasmic, and nuclear rim regions. These segmentation algorithms followed the basic algorithmic structure of edge detection, then edge completion, followed by automatic extraneous object exclusion. Nuclear fluorescence measurements were derived simply as mean nuclear pixel intensity, whereas cytoplasmic fluorescence was obtained from a k-means analysis of the extranuclear pixels (this analysis was calibrated to exclude dark vacuolar regions and the bleed-through light at perinuclear regions). Where possible, the scripts calculated nuclear rim fluorescence by tracing the brightest pixels around the periphery of the nuclear regions and then averaged this summed pixel intensity over perimeter distance. This analysis was performed to derive N/C fluorescence ratios and nuclear rim intensity measurements for 98–1,401 individual cells from each of the 27 strain-reporter combinations; a total of 9,621 cells were thus measured using these methods.
Statistical regression analysis
Statistical regression analysis using LASSO was done using the MatLab implementation of LASSO. LASSO is particularly suitable for finding statistical correlations in small datasets, because it deploys a regularization scheme that effectively penalizes solutions with a larger number of variables, thereby reducing the risk of overfitting (Tibshirani, 1996).
For each of 13 strains (WT plus 12 mutant strains with FG repeat deletions), 33 features (Fig. S5 and Tables S3 and S4) that quantitatively describe the NPC composition, geometry, and biophysical properties of that strain were gathered. A 13 × 33 matrix M was constructed, with Mij being the value of the j’th feature in the i’th strain. The regression analysis aimed to create a predictor from the rows of M (the vectors of features for each strain). The columns of M (the vectors of each feature) were centered by subtractions of their mean and normalized by division with their standard errors. In addition, a 13-dimensional response vector Y was constructed with the WT relative permeability of each strain, formally defined as the ratio between the permeability of each strain and the WT permeability, averaged across all cargo types for which a measurement was taken in that strain. The regression analysis aimed to create a predictor from the rows of M (the feature vector of each strain) to Y. Conversely, each feature was represented as a 13-dimensional feature vector f, in which each vector coordinate fj represents the value of that feature in strain j. The coordinates of f and s were normalized by subtracting the feature mean and dividing by the feature SD across all mutant strains.
To remove strong statistical redundancies that obscure the regression analysis, we first clustered the 33 feature vectors using their mutual Pearson’s correlation values and randomly selected representative features from cliques of features in which all pairs of features had Pearson’s correlation >0.9. We then applied PCA to further eliminate redundant degrees of freedom while maximizing the information content in each selected degree of freedom (Jolliffe, 1982). We applied the PCA/LASSO method iteratively, removing features that were selected with extremely low weights until the process converged on a final list of eight features from two highly correlated subgroups that are predicted to have the greatest effect on passive transport rates (features related to charge to hydrophobicity and features related to proximity to the cytoplasmic end of the pore).
Online supplemental material
Fig. S1 shows supporting analyses of shape effects in relation to Fig. 3. Fig. S2 shows the thermodynamics and kinetics of simulated passive diffusion in relation to Fig. 4. Fig. S3 shows the general effect on the transport machinery in FG deletion strains, providing controls for our measurements of passive diffusion. Fig. S4 shows Kap123 dynamics, which seem independent of passive NPC permeability, but are greatly reduced upon deletion of particular FG regions. Fig. S5 shows relative transport times plotted as a function of individual features of the mutant strains and the corresponding R2 correlation coefficients. Fig. S6 shows an assessment of the robustness of positive and negative contribution of various FG Nup features in the combined PCA/LASSO regression model of passive transport in different settings. Fig. S7 shows a sequence and spatial analysis of the different FG Nups and mutant strains. Fig. S8 shows the change in the ratio between nuclear and cytoplasmic fluorescence at equilibrium relative to the WT strain for the different GFP-xPrA substrates in the nup116ΔFG strain. Video 1 shows FRAP permeability assays of four representative WT cells, each expressing a different-sized GFP-xPrA substrate. Video 2 shows sample simulation trajectory of passive diffusion of macromolecules of different molecular masses/radii through the NPC, using the model described in the text and in Fig. 4 and Fig. S2. Table S1 shows the plasmids used in this study. Table S2 shows the strains used in this study. Table S3 shows the features used to describe the NPCs of mutant strains and for the regression analysis. Table S4 shows the SAXS measurements of maximal end-to-end distances and radii of gyration for GFP-xPrA and GFP-xPrG molecules.
We thank Liesbeth Veenhoff and Patrick Onck for helpful discussion, sharing of unpublished data, and critical reading of the manuscript; and Laura Terry, who assisted in the assembly of strains for these studies.
This work was supported by National Institutes of Health grants P41 GM109824 (to M.P. Rout and A. Sali), R01 GM112108 (to M.P. Rout and A. Sali), U01 GM098256 (to M.P. Rout and A. Sali), and R01 GM071329 (to M.P. Rout).
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator
nuclear pore complex
nuclear transport receptor
principal component analysis
small-angle x-ray scattering
B.L. Timney and B. Raveh contributed equally to this paper.