To elucidate the contribution of the extracellular microfibril–elastic fiber network to vertebrate organogenesis, we generated fibrillin 2 (Fbn2)–null mice by gene targeting and identified a limb-patterning defect in the form of bilateral syndactyly. Digit fusion involves both soft and hard tissues, and is associated with reduced apoptosis at affected sites. Two lines of evidence suggest that syndactily is primarily due to defective mesenchyme differentiation, rather than reduced apoptosis of interdigital tissue. First, fusion occurs before appearance of interdigital cell death; second, interdigital tissues having incomplete separation fail to respond to apoptotic clues from implanted BMP-4 beads. Syndactyly is associated with a disorganized matrix, but with normal BMP gene expression. On the other hand, mice double heterozygous for null Fbn2 and Bmp7 alleles display the combined digit phenotype of both nullizygotes. Together, these results imply functional interaction between Fbn2-rich microfibrils and BMP-7 signaling. As such, they uncover an unexpected relationship between the insoluble matrix and soluble factors during limb patterning. We also demonstrate that the Fbn2- null mutation is allelic to the recessive shaker-with-syndactyly (sy) locus on chromosome 18.
Limb patterning is controlled by complex interactions of four signaling centers that promote establishment of the main axes, growth, and cell differentiation (Johnson and Tabin, 1997; Tickle, 1999). The apical ectodermal ridge and the underlying progress zone regulate proximal-distal outgrowth of the limb bud, and proliferation of undifferentiated mesenchyme, respectively. During the late phase of limb morphogenesis, rays of condensing mesenchyme appear in the distal region of the bud (autopod); they grow and differentiate into cartilage (digits), whereas interposed tissues (interdigits) undergo programmed cell death. Therefore, digit formation is the combined result of chondrogenic outgrowth and interdigital cell death. In turn, the choice of autopodial mesoderm to undergo either chondrogenesis or apoptosis is primarily determined by positional information established earlier in ontogeny. At least three bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs),*
Abbreviations used in this paper: BMP, bone morphogenetic protein; CCA, congenital contractural arachnodactyly; ES, embryonic stem; Fbn, fibrillin; sy, shaker-with-syndactyly; TUNEL, Tdt-mediated dUTP nick end labeling.
The extracellular matrix consists of a highly heterogeneous mixture of insoluble and soluble molecules that orchestrate a variety of cellular processes and developmental programs. Extracellular microfibrils, alone or associated with elastin in the elastic fiber, confer critical properties to the connective tissue of the developing and adult organism (Ramirez, 1996). Microfibril–elastic fiber networks vary greatly in length, thickness, and tridimensional organization in order to accommodate the strength and direction of mechanical forces experienced by individual tissues (Mecham and Davis, 1994). It is widely believed that the morphological diversification of the insoluble matrix may also reflect nonstructural roles. For example, transient appearance of an elastic scaffold in the limb bud of the chick embryo was interpreted to suggest that this specialized matrix may physically delineate the location and size of cartilaginous structures (Hurlé et al., 1994). Indeed, ectopic stimulation of chondrogenesis at interdigital sites was shown to be preceded by disruption of the elastic scaffold and substantial matrix reorganization (Hurlé et al., 1994). However, the role of extracellular macroaggregates in demarcating specific areas in developing tissues has never been formally or genetically proven.
Another evolving concept is that the insoluble matrix may also modulate intercellular signaling by guiding the diffusion, sequestration, activation, or presentation of soluble factors to the surrounding cells (Flaumenhaft and Rifkin, 1991). A case in point is the postulated regulation by microfibrils of transforming growth factor-β activity through binding of the large latent complex (Taipale and Keski-Oja, 1997). The glycoproteins fibrillin 1 (Fbn1) and fibrillin 2 (Fbn2) are the major, if not the only, structural components of extracellular microfibrils (Handford et al., 2000). Fbn gene expression and microfibrillar deposition precede elastic fiber formation, which in most tissues occurs between midgestation and early postnatal life (Mecham and Davis, 1994). Mutations in the human Fbn1 and Fbn2 genes are responsible for the pleiotropic manifestations of Marfan syndrome and the transient phenotype of congenital contractural arachnodactyly (CCA), respectively (Ramirez, 1996). Mice harboring targeted mutations in the Fbn1 gene have demonstrated that Marfan syndrome severity is determined by the degree of functional impairment of extracellular microfibrils (Pereira et al., 1997, 1999; Gayraud et al., 2000). Moreover, the longer bones of Fbn1-deficient mice lend credence to the hypothesis that microfibrils play a role in skeletal development (Pereira et al., 1999).
In contrast to the emerging information about Fbn1 biology, little is known about the role of Fbn2 during embryonic development. Here we report the creation of a null allele of the mouse Fbn2 gene. Mutant homozygotes recapitulate the human CCA phenotype, and also display bilateral syndactyly of forelimbs and hindlimbs. The patterning abnormality appears early in autopod formation, and before apoptotic cells are observed in the interdigital tissues. We show that Fbn2 deficiency is associated with disorganized microfibrils, and provide genetic evidence for interaction between Fbn2 and BMP-7. Altogether, the results demonstrate for the first time that specific intercellular signaling events during limb morphogenesis depend on proper supramolecular assembly of the insoluble extracellular matrix.
Results And Discussion
Generation of Fbn2−/−mice
To create a null Fbn2 allele, the 1.2-kb region encompassing exon 1 was replaced by the pGK-neo cassette (Fig. 1
a). Exon 1 contains the 5′ untranslated region of the mRNA, in addition to coding for the signal peptide and the first 85 amino acids of the protein (Zhang et al., 1995). After electroporation of the targeting vector and selection of G418-resistant embryonic stem (ES) clones carrying the recombinant allele (Fig. 1 b), three chimeric animals were generated and germ line transmission of the mutant allele was demonstrated in one of them by Southern hybridization (Fig. 1 c). Northern analysis of newborn lung RNA, and Western analysis of conditioned media from fibroblast cultures documented loss of Fbn2 gene activity in homozygous mutant animals (Fig. 1, d and e).
Mating of heterozygous mutant animals led to the production of Fbn2−/− mice in the pure (129/Sv) and hybrid (C57Bl/6Jx129/Sv) genetic backgrounds. Heterozygous and homozygous mutant mice were born at the expected frequency, and were viable and fertile. Examination of newborn Fbn2−/− mice revealed contractures of carpal, metacarpal, and phalangeal joints in the forelimbs (Fig. 2
a); upon mechanical extension, the large joints of the hindlimbs were felt to be stiffer than those of wild-type littermates. As with CCA patients (Ramirez, 1996), contractures in Fbn2-deficient mice disappeared within the first few days of postnatal life. The presence of contractures in heterozygous CCA patients and in homozygous mice indicates a pathogenic equivalency between dominant-negative and loss-of-function mutations of Fbn2.
Limb skeletal abnormalities
Examination of Fbn2-deficient mice identified an additional unexpected trait, bilateral syndactily, indicative of a morphogenetic role of the extracellular protein (Fig. 2 b). The phenotype is fully penetrant and shows variable expression in different backgrounds, suggestive of genetic modifier(s) (Table I)
. Complete fusion or close apposition of chondrogenic elements of the central two or three digits (digits 2–4) was observed in both forelimbs and hindlimbs (Table I). Syndactyly always involves the first phalange, thus suggesting that the perturbation occurs early during proximal-distal outgrowth of the autopod (Fig. 2 b). This postulate was corroborated by the finding of malformed autopods in mutant embryos before the appearance of interdigital cell death (Fig. 2 c) (Chen and Zhao, 1998). It was also confirmed experimentally by comparing the effect of exogenous BMP administration to interdigital rays of mutant and wild-type embryos (Fig. 2 d). Implantation of latex beads loaded with BMP-2, BMP-4, or BMP-7 into chick interdigital tissues has been shown to induce Msx gene expression and precocious cell death (Ganan et al., 1996, 1998; Macias et al., 1997; Merino et al., 1998). Increased expression of Msx1 and Msx2 genes in response to local BMP-4 administration was indeed observed in wild-type interdigital tissues, as well as in unaffected regions of Fbn2 mutant interdigital rays (Fig. 2 d). In contrast, there was no significant increase of Msx gene activity around BMP-4 beads implanted into mutant interdigital tissues having incomplete separation (Fig. 2 d). It should be noted that the data shown in Fig. 2 d were obtained with mutant limbs incubated for a longer period than wild-type autopod, in order to maximize the effect of the implanted beads. Accumulation of Msx transcripts at the tip of the autopod is consistent with the normal pattern of gene expression during limb development (see below and Fig. 2 e). Altogether, the data strongly suggest that Fbn2 deficiency negatively affects promotion of mesenchyme differentiation during early autopod morphogenesis, rather than subsequent interdigital apoptosis. The precise cellular lesion (i.e., commitment vs. proliferation of presumptive interdigital cells) remains to be determined. At variance with previous antisense interference experiments in rat organ cultures, we did not find evidence of impaired branching morphogenesis in Fbn2−/− lungs (Yang et al., 1999). This discrepancy may reflect the contribution of additional cellular factors present in vivo and absent in isolated organ cultures.
Fbn2 deficiency is associated with reduced apoptosis of interdigital tissue
BMP activation of programmed cell death correlates with induction of Msx gene expression (Marazzi et al., 1997). Accordingly, we analyzed expression of Msx genes in Fbn2 mutant autopods. We also examined expression of genes coding for regulators of autopod morphogenesis, including Fgf-8, a major signaling molecule secreted by the apical ectodermal ridge during proximal-dorsal limb outgrowth, and Bmp-4, a representative of BMPs involved in digit formation (Hogan, 1996; Johnson and Tabin, 1997; Tickle, 1999). Consistent with digit fusion, there was no detectable Msx expression in the affected regions of mutant interdigital rays (Fig. 2 e). Histological analyses using the Tdt-mediated dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL) assay corroborated this finding. Visualization of apoptotic signals in the interdigital rays of mutant embryos did in fact document the presence of fewer dying cells in affected compared with unaffected tissues (Fig. 2 f). Consistent with the notion that the mutation affects early morphogenesis, apoptosis is impaired but not abolished by loss of Fbn2. In contrast to the Msx genes, neither Fgf-8 nor Bmp-4 are abnormally expressed in mutant autopods (Fig. 2 g). Normal Bmp gene expression in the presence of reduced apoptosis raised the possibility that alterations of the autopodial matrix may perturb sequestration and/or activation of intercellular signaling molecules.
Fbn2 deficiency alters microfibrillar organization and BMP signaling
Two distinct experiments were performed to validate the above hypothesis. In the first, we examined the morphology of microfibrillar aggregates during autopod development. Analysis of Fbn1 and Fbn2 expression documented that both transcripts accumulate predominantly, but not exclusively, in the interdigital rays (Fig. 3
a). Indirect immunofluorescence using specific antisera for Fbn1 and Fbn2 proteins, as well as for the cartilage-specific type II collagen, provided an overview of the arrangement of these extracellular macroaggregates in the wild-type and mutant autopods (Fig. 3 b). Whereas the Fbn-rich network of the wild-type embryo is distinctly arranged in the digital and interdigital rays (Fig. 3 b, top), that of the mutant is significantly disorganized with little or no Fbn immunoreactivity in the interdigital rays (Fig. 3 b, bottom). This last finding implies that Fbn2 is required for proper microfibrillar assembly; the requirement is tissue specific, in that networks of other organs are morphologically normal (Fig. 3 c).
The second test was designed to assess whether a functional connection exists between Fbn2 and BMP-7, one of the soluble regulators of digit formation (Hogan, 1996; Tickle 1999). To this end, we generated a compound heterozygous for Fbn2- and Bmp-7–null alleles. Whereas heterozygous Bmp-7–null mice are viable and morphologically normal, homozygotes die soon after birth and display several developmental abnormalities, including polydactily (Dudley et al., 1995; Luo et al., 1995). Analysis of Fbn2+/−/Bmp-7+/− mice revealed a limb phenotype that combines the patterning defects (syndactyly and polydactyly) of each nullyzgous mouse (Fig. 4
a). Appearance of the null phenotype in the presence of half of the normal complement of each gene product implies functional interaction between the two proteins. This interaction in turn demonstrates that Fbn2 and BMP-7 are part of the same genetic program that regulates digit formation during autopod development.
Fbn2-null mutation is allelic to the sy locus on chromosome 18
There are several naturally occurring and artificially generated mutations in mice that affect limb development and patterning. One such mutation is the radiation-induced recessive locus shaker-with-syndactyly (sy), which is located on the same region of chromosome 18, where Fbn2 resides (Hertwig, 1942; Lane et al., 1981; Li et al., 1993). Spontaneous mutations at the sy locus (syfp and sy fp-2) that are viable in homozygosity and that only exhibit syndactyly have been described previously (Lane and Hummel, 1973; Sweet, 1996). Recent genomic analyses have suggested that sy is a multigene deletion of ∼1 cM (Johnson et al., 1998). Hybridization of sy DNA to Fbn2 probes demonstrated that the deletion includes the whole gene (unpublished data). Generation of double Fbn2−/+/syfp/+ heterozygotes revealed that they exhibit the same bilateral syndactyly as Fbn2−/−or syfp/syfp mice. Sequencing of RT-PCR products covering the entire Fbn2 transcript from homozygous syfp mice identified a frameshift mutation that introduces an early termination codon at amino acid 1728, which is expected to destabilize the mRNA. Northern and Western analyses confirmed this last postulate by documenting absence Fbn2 mRNA and protein in syfp/syfp samples, respectively. (Fig. 4, b and c). Hence, loss of function of Fbn2 is the genetic lesion causing syndactyly in the contiguous gene deletion syndrome of the sy mouse.
This study identifies Fbn2 as the first insoluble matrix component to regulate limb patterning. This conclusion is based on two lines of evidence. First, altered microfibrillar morphology in mutant autopods implies a causal relationship between the organization of the insoluble macroaggregate and the patterning defect. Second, defective digit morphogenesis in double heterozygous Fbn2+/−/Bmp7+/− mice indicates functional interaction between the matrix component and the growth factor. Hence, interactions with the microfibrillar network apparently control the distribution and/or activity of intercellular signals in the developing limb. The effect is highly specific in that it is restricted to a specific tissue and morphogenetic program.
A variety of extracellular modulators are known to be involved in intercellular signaling, including extracellular proteins that control signal availability, such as proteoglycans and tissue proteases (Christian, 2000). To the best of our knowledge, this is the first instance in which evidence has been presented for the involvement of an insoluble matrix macroaggregate in the control of a specific patterning event. Thus more generally, the insoluble matrix may provide the structural scaffold that arranges morphogenetic clues in the intercellular space of the developing organism. This function could be exerted by binding directly to inactive growth factors (such as in the case of the latent transforming growth factor-β complex), indirectly through interaction with other matrix components (such as proteoglycans), or by a combination of both mechanisms (Flaumenhaft and Rifkin, 1991; Taipale and Keski-Oja, 1997). Irrespectively, our study demonstrates that the tridimensional organization of insoluble extracellular macroaggregates is critically important in establishing morphogenetic gradients during vertebrate embryogenesis.
Materials And Methods
Gene targeting and mouse lines
The Fbn2 targeting vector was engineered according to the gene replacement strategy outlined in Fig. 1 a. The 8.8-kb ApaI genomic fragment lying 5′ of exon 1 of Fbn2, was subcloned in the pBluescript SK(+/−) vector (Stratagene). The 2.3-kb SacI-BglI fragment extending 3′ of exon 1 and including exon 2, was then ligated into the blunt-ended NotI site. Finally, the 1.8-kb SalI-XhoI fragment from pGEM7(KJ1) plasmid containing the neomycin resistance gene (pGK-neo), was inserted into the XhoI site located between the homology regions and opposite of Fbn2 transcription. The targeting construct was electroporated into ES cells that were selected as described previously (Pereira et al., 1997, 1999). Southern blots were performed with a probe outside of the homology region (probe 3 A) that recognizes 16-kb wild-type and 1-kb mutant bands in BamHI-digested DNA, as well as 14-kb wild-type and 11.5-kb mutant bands in SphI-digested DNA (Fig. 1 a). Chimeric animals were generated in the Mouse Genetics Shared Research Facility (Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York, NY) according to the previously published protocol (Pereira et al., 1997, 1999). After germ line transmission, the Fbn2 mutation was maintained in the hybrid (C57Bl/6Jx129/Sv) and pure (129/Sv) genetic background. The syfp/+ mouse line and DNA from homozygous sy mice were obtained from The Jackson Laboratory, whereas Bmp7 mutant mice were provided by Dr. L. Robertson (Harvard Medical School, Cambridge, MA) (Dudley et al., 1995).
Northern blot analysis was performed on ∼40 μg of total RNA purified from newborn lungs (Pereira et al., 1997); probes included the 3′ untranslated regions of Fbn1 and Fbn2, and the control GAPDH (Zhang et al., 1995). In situ and whole-mount hybridizations were performed as described previously using the same Fbn probes (Sumiyoshi et al., 2001). Additional in situ hybridization probes included the 3′ untranslated regions of Msx1, Msx2, Bmp-4, and Fgf-8 (Marazzi et al., 1997; Semba et al., 2000). RT-PCR screening of the mutant Fbn2 transcript was performed using overlapping oligonucleotides that cover the entire gene (Zhang et al., 1995).
The anti-Fbn1 antibody, pAb9543, was prepared using the Fbn1 NH2-terminal half-recombinant polypeptide rF11 (Reinhardt et al., 1996). The mouse Fbn2 antibody was raised in the rabbit against the recombinant NH2-terminal peptide rF37. The antibody was tested by ELISA against the immunizing peptide, and specificity was determined by Western blot analysis. The type II collagen monoclonal antibody was obtained from the Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank (University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA). Western blot analyses were performed on conditioned media of primary dermal fibroblasts established from newborn Fbn2−/− and syfp/syfp mice (Gayraud et al., 2000). Antibodies were visualized with nitro blue tetrazolium/5-bromo-4-chloro-3′ indoylphosphate (Pierce Chemical Co.). For indirect immunofluorescence, fresh limbs were fixed in 2% paraformaldehyde, 0.75 M lysine, and 0.01 M sodium periodate in 1× PBS for ∼4 h at 4°C, washed in 1× PBS for 1 h at 4°C, and stabilized in 40% sucrose in 1× PBS for 24 h at 4°C. The tissue was then embedded in OCT compound (Tissue Tek) and frozen in liquid nitrogen. 5 μm sections were generated using a Leica cryostat and diamond-coated disposable blades (C. L. Sturkey) and mounted on Fisherbrand Superfrost glass slides. Sections were dried at room temperature for 1 h and stored at 4°C. Immunostaining was performed as described previously (Gayraud et al., 2000), and fluorescence was monitored using a Zeiss Axiophot microscope using 10× or 20× Plan-Neofluar objective. Images were taken with a Spot camera (Diagnostic Instrument) and processed using Photoshop 5.5.
Adult mice were anesthetized by intraperitoneal injection of 0.017 ml of 25% Avitin per gram weight, and embryos were fixed in Bouin's fixative. Whole-mount pictures were taken using a Nikon SMZ-U dissecting scope and a Sony digital photo camera (model DKC-5000); images were processed using Photoshop 5.5. For whole-mount skeletal analysis, mice were fixed overnight in 95% ethanol after removing soft tissue. Cartilage was stained in a fresh solution of 80 ml 95% ethanol, 20 ml glacial acetic acid, and 15–30 mg alcian blue (Sigma-Aldrich) for 12–48 h. Skeleton was washed twice in 95% ethanol, and soft tissue was dissolved overnight in 2% KOH. Bones were stained overnight in 1% KOH, 75 μg/ml alizarin red S (Sigma-Aldrich), destained in 20% glycerol and 1% KOH for 3–7 d, and cleared first in 20% glycerol and 20% ethanol, and then in 50% glycerol and 50% ethanol. Images were prepared as described above. X-ray radiographs were performed on anesthesized mice using a Micro 50 (Microfocus Imaging) at 30 kV for 20–30 s. In situ TUNEL assay on paraffin sections was performed using the Apoptosis Detection System (Promega).
Affi-Gel blue agarose beads (Bio-Rad Laboratories) at 100–200 mesh (50–75 μm) were soaked in 100 ng/μl human recombinant BMP-4 (Genetics Institute) or in BSA, and implanted into interdigital tissue of E13.5 hindlimbs as described previously (Semba et al., 2000). After 6 h incubation at 37°C in 5% CO2, limbs were processed for in situ hybridization.
The authors thank Drs. M. Amling, M. Baron, T. Lufkin, L. Robertson, V. Rosen, and D. Sassoon for suggestions and critical reagents, and Ms. Karen Johnson for typing the manuscript.
This work was supported by grants from the National Institutes of Health (AR42044, GM18511), the National Marfan Foundation, and the Shriners Foundation.