Table A2.

Competing model formulations

Model Normalized force: Normalized recruitment term: Normalized distortion term: Second order terms: No. of parameters: 
 φ(t) = dε(t)dt= dζ(t)dt=   
I ε(t)ζ(t) −bε(t)+b[λ(t)−λd1−λd] −c[ζ(t)−1]+1υ0dλ(t)dt — Three: b and c (with units of s−1) and υ0 (unit-less) 
II ε(t)ζ(t) −(b+γ f(x))ε(t)+b[λ(t)−λd1−λd] −c[ζ(t)−1]+1υ0dλ(t)dt — Four: b, γ, and c (with units of s−1) and υ0 (unit-less) 
III ε(t)ζ(t) −b(1+γ f(x))ε(t)+b[λ(t)−λd1−λd] −c(1+γ f(x))[ζ(t)−1]+1υ0dl(t)dt — Four: b and c (with units of s−1) and γ and υ0 (unit-less) 
IV ε(t)ζ(t) −(b+γη f(x))ε(t)+b[λ(t)−λd1−λd] −(c+γx f(x))[ζ(t)−1]+1υ0dl(t)dt — Five: b and c (with units of s−1) and γn, γx, and υ0 (unit-less) 
V ε(t)[ζ(t) + κζ1(t)] −(b+γ f(x))ε(t)+b[λ(t)−λd1−λd] −c[ζ(t)−1]+1υ0dλ(t)dt dζ1(t)dt=−dζ1(t)+1υ0dλ(t)dt Six: b, γ, c, and d (with units of s-−1) and κ and υ0 (unit-less) 
VI ε(t)ζ(t) −(b+γ f(x))ε(t)+b[ε1(t)] −c[ζ(t)−1]+1υ0dλ(t)dt dε1(t)dt=−a(ε1(t)−λ(t)−λd1−λd−θdλ(t)dt) Six: b, γ, c, and a (with units of s−1) and θ and υ0 (unit-less) 

Model legend: I, simple RD model; II, RD model with nonlinear interaction term (NLRD model); III, NLRD model with nonlinear distortion effect on distortion (same nonlinear effect of distortion on both recruitment and distortion); IV, NLRD model with nonlinear distortion effect on distortion (same nonlinear effect of distortion on both recruitment and distortion); V, NLRD model with second-order distortion term; VI, NLRD model with second-order recruitment term.

or Create an Account

Close subscription notice
Close access options