The muscular dystrophies are a group of heterogeneous genetic diseases characterized by progressive degeneration and weakness of skeletal muscle. Since the discovery of the first muscular dystrophy gene encoding dystrophin, a large number of genes have been identified that are involved in various muscle-wasting and neuromuscular disorders. Human genetic studies complemented by animal model systems have substantially contributed to our understanding of the molecular pathomechanisms underlying muscle degeneration. Moreover, these studies have revealed distinct molecular and cellular mechanisms that link genetic mutations to diverse muscle wasting phenotypes.
Skeletal muscle is a highly specialized organ system evolved for locomotion and energy metabolism in multicellular organisms. Deterioration of muscle cell integrity as a result of genetic mutations leads to progressive muscle wasting with detrimental consequences including early death. Typically, mutations in different genes tend to target distinct muscle groups, on the basis of which these conditions have been subdivided into several groups. However, mutations in different regions of the same protein, or even identical mutations, have also been implicated in clinically distinct phenotypes. Gene mapping efforts in families with affected individuals have been instrumental in elucidating the underlying cellular and molecular processes perturbed in most of these diseases. Mutations in a wide range of proteins, including many structural proteins and enzymes that posttranslationally modify some of these proteins have been implicated in muscular dystrophy. A comprehensive review of all types of muscular dystrophies and myopathies is beyond the scope of this review. A revised list of causative genes and reclassification is annually reported by the journal Neuromuscular Disorders (Kaplan and Hamroun, 2012). Here we will discuss distinct disease mechanisms of several well-understood muscular dystrophies and highlight several recently identified genes that will likely uncover novel cellular mechanisms underlying disease.
The structure of skeletal muscle cells
The myofiber is the functional unit of skeletal muscle and is a multinucleated tubular structure formed from the fusion of multiple mononucleated muscle cells (myoblasts). Myoblasts are generated by asymmetric division and differentiation of muscle stem cells, called satellite cells, that are located between the muscle cell membrane (sarcolemma) and basal lamina (Mauro, 1961). In addition to typical cellular organelles, the cytoplasm (sarcoplasm) of a myofiber contains a regular array of contractile units (sarcomeres) comprised of actin-containing thin filaments and myosin-containing thick filaments that, along with additional structural and regulatory proteins, are arranged longitudinally as myofibrils. The peripheral myofibrils are connected to the sarcolemma along the Z-disks via interactions with subsarcolemmal protein complexes called costameres. These structures transmit contractile forces from sarcomeres of one myofiber to another, which prevents sarcolemma ruptures by synchronizing contraction of myofibers within a muscle. Sarcolemma is firmly attached to the basal lamina, which consists of ECM proteins. Failure to attach properly results in sarcolemmal disruption, which is the predominant underlying cause of several forms of muscular dystrophies. Cross-section of healthy muscle reveals myofibers that are roughly equal in diameter with multiple nuclei pushed to the periphery of the cell. However, dystrophic muscle displays centrally located nuclei and myofibers of variable size, which are caused by successive rounds of degeneration and regeneration. Extensive damage to muscle activates satellite cells to promote muscle regeneration. Although these cells are replenished by self-renewal, recurrent degeneration and regeneration of skeletal muscle in disease state depletes the satellite cell pool and fails to further regenerate the muscle contributing to muscle wasting (Collins et al., 2005). Furthermore, atrophied muscle is gradually substituted by fibrous and fatty tissues, which is one of the hallmarks of muscular dystrophy. Disruption of sarcolemma causes leakage of muscle proteins such as creatine kinase (CK) into the serum. Thus, highly elevated CK concentration in circulating blood serum is used as an informative biomarker for degenerative processes occurring in muscle. However, the precise diagnosis of muscular dystrophies needs to be determined by a combination of protein testing with immunostaining or immunoblotting on a muscle biopsy followed by targeted genetic testing. Even though the end point of these conditions is severe muscle loss and accumulation of fibrotic and fatty tissues, different molecular pathomechanisms have been implicated in distinct types of muscle disease.
Cellular and molecular mechanisms of muscle degeneration
Disruption of cytoskeleton–ECM connection.
The most common and severely debilitating neuromuscular disorder, Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), affects ∼1 in 3,500 males. It is manifested by rapidly progressive proximal muscle wasting starting around 3 years of age, culminating with respiratory insufficiency and cardiac failure that leads to premature death by the mid-20s. The allelic disorder Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) is less common and milder, with late disease onset and relatively advanced survival age. Both diseases are caused by mutations in the DMD gene, the largest gene in the human genome, located on the X chromosome, which encodes the 427-kD protein dystrophin (Monaco et al., 1986; Burghes et al., 1987; Hoffman et al., 1987; Koenig et al., 1987). DMD is caused by recessive, frameshifting deletions and duplications or nonsense mutations that lead to complete loss of or expression of nonfunctional dystrophin in myofibers, whereas mutations causing BMD produce semifunctional dystrophin (Hoffman et al., 1988; Monaco et al., 1988; Koenig et al., 1989). Dystrophin is an intracellular, rod-shaped protein with four major functional domains. This protein is localized to the inner surface of the sarcolemma, with a high abundance at costameres. The N terminal and a portion of the middle rod domain interact with the cytoskeletal filamentous actin (F-actin), whereas the C-terminal domain interacts with multiple proteins to assemble the dystrophin-associated protein complex (DAPC), a group of proteins that span the sarcolemma of the skeletal and cardiac muscle (Ervasti et al., 1990; Yoshida and Ozawa, 1990; Fig. 1 A). This protein complex, in addition to dystrophin, encompasses intracellular (α1- and β1-syntrophin, α-dystrobrevin, and nNOS), transmembrane (β-dystroglycan, α-, β-, γ-, and δ-sarcoglycan, and sarcospan), and extracellular proteins (α-dystroglycan and laminin-2). The core component of the DAPC, dystroglycan, is encoded by a single gene and posttranslationally cleaved to yield two noncovalently associated subunits. The transmembrane subunit β-dystroglycan binds to dystrophin and other cytolinker proteins at the intracellular periphery of sarcolemma, whereas the cell-surface subunit α-dystroglycan binds to β-dystroglycan and to the ECM proteins such as laminin-2; together, these proteins connect the intracellular cytoskeleton through sarcolemma with the basement membrane (Ibraghimov-Beskrovnaya et al., 1992). The integrity of this protein complex is crucial for the contracting myofiber to withstand the mechanical stress generated by sarcomeres and to prevent its fragile sarcolemma from contraction-induced injuries (Petrof et al., 1993). Disruption of the DAPC, as a result of structural or posttranslational defects in one of the components building this protein complex, weakens the sarcolemma and causes different types of muscular dystrophy depending on the altered protein. The subcomplex of integral proteins sarcoglycans and sarcospan within the DAPC provides additional mechanical support to the DAPC and thereby to the sarcolemma (Yoshida et al., 1994). Mutations in genes encoding the α, β, γ, and δ subunits of the sarcoglycan complex cause sarcoglycanopathies, a subtype of recessively inherited limb-girdle muscular dystrophies (LGMDs; Table 1). In general, structural defects in one sarcoglycan subunit lead to reduction or complete loss of the other subunits, destabilizing the entire protein complex, which consequently weakens the sarcolemma. LGMDs are the most heterogeneous subgroup of muscular dystrophies that predominantly involve the proximal limb-girdle musculature, mainly those around hips and shoulders. Besides sarcoglycanopathies, there are several additional LGMDs with distinct molecular underpinnings that can arise as a result of mutations in proteins unrelated to the DAPC, each type categorized based on the mode of inheritance and altered gene product.
Aberrant glycosylation of α-dystroglycan.
During posttranslational maturation, the mucin domain of α-dystroglycan undergoes extensive O-glycosylation at serine/threonine residues catalyzed by multiple enzymes residing in the Golgi apparatus and sarcoplasmic reticulum in a stepwise manner. The branched O-linked carbohydrate moieties are required for high-affinity binding to G domain–containing proteins of the ECM such as laminin 2, agrin, and perlecan (Barresi and Campbell, 2006). Hypoglycosylation of α-dystroglycan diminishes its binding capacity to the ECM proteins and destabilizes the sarcolemma. Functional impairment of several known or putative glycosyltransferases as a result of genetic mutations causes them to fail to properly glycosylate the α-dystroglycan protein and leads to a clinically heterogeneous group of congenital muscular dystrophies (CMDs): Walker-Warburg syndrome (WWS), muscle-eye-brain disease (MEB), and Fukuyama CMD (Michele et al., 2002; Moore et al., 2002). In addition to hypotonia and severe muscle weakness, present at birth or thereafter, the affected individuals suffer from severe brain and eye malformations. To date, recessive mutations in 10 genes have been identified in ∼50% of individuals with CMD (Table 1), and the number of causative genes is increasing rapidly with the advent of whole-exome sequencing. Mutations in these genes produce a wide spectrum of clinical severity that lead to recent reclassification of the most severe forms of CMD—WWS, MEB, and Fukuyama CMD—as muscular dystrophy-dystroglycanopathy type A (MDDGA). An intermediate form, with or without cognitive impairment, is designated as MDDGB, and the least severe form with no cognitive impairment and manifested as later onset LGMD is designated as MDDGC (Table 1). However, in the majority of cases the causative gene is difficult to predict from the clinical phenotype. Because these disorders are not caused by mutations in the dystroglycan gene itself, but rather by insufficient posttranslational glycosylation of the protein, they are often classified as secondary dystroglycanopathies. A missense change of a highly conserved amino acid (Thr192Met) in dystroglycan was recently identified in an individual affected with LGMD and cognitive impairment, the first reported case of a primary dystroglycanopathy within this disease classification (Hara et al., 2011). Functional studies, including a mutation knock-in mouse model, determined that this mutation interferes with LARGE-mediated maturation of phosphorylated O-mannosyl glycans on α-dystroglycan, thereby decreasing its binding efficiency to laminin.
Loss of integrin-mediated linkage between cytoskeleton and ECM.
Similar to the DAPC, the α7β1 integrin heterodimer connects the actin cytoskeleton to the ECM (Fig. 1 A). Mutations in ITGA7 encoding the α7 chain of α7β1 integrin cause CMD (Hayashi et al., 1998). In developing myoblasts, α7β1 integrin plays a role in cell adhesion, proliferation, and differentiation. In mature myofibers, it is expressed throughout the sarcolemma to reinforce its attachment to the basal lamina, and in particular these proteins are concentrated at costameres, neuromuscular junctions (NMJs), and myotendinous junctions (MTJs). Targeted deletion of the α7 chain causes progressive muscle degeneration with specific impairment of function at the MTJ (Mayer et al., 1997). Loss of the DAPC in DMD muscle increases the amount α7β1 integrin at the sarcolemma, likely to compensate for the weakened link between the sarcolemma and basal lamina. Furthermore, transgenic overexpression of α7β1 integrin reduced sarcolemma damage and significantly ameliorated disease symptoms in mdx mice, the most widely used animal model for DMD with a nonsense mutation in Dmd (Burkin et al., 2001; Liu et al., 2012). The integrin linkage system appears to functionally complement the DAPC-mediated linkage between the cytoskeleton and the ECM. Therefore, enhancing sarcolemmal expression of the integrin heterodimers provides a potential therapeutic approach for DMD and other muscular dystrophies caused by loss of the DAPC.
Disruption of the ECM.
The ECM is a meshwork of glycoproteins, collagen, and proteoglycans that provides an attachment and signaling scaffold for myofibers. Mutations in several genes encoding the structural components of the ECM are responsible for CMDs. The most common form of CMD, merosin-deficient or type 1A (MDC1A), is caused by the deficiency of laminin-α2 chain (LAMA2; Helbling-Leclerc et al., 1995). Secondary loss of laminin-α2 is common to severe forms of CMD caused by mutations in other genes (Brockington et al., 2001). Laminin-α2 is one of the three subunits of muscle-specific laminin that makes distinct interacting complexes with the DAPC through glycosylated α-dystroglycan and with the α7β1 integrin dimer. These protein complexes are secreted from myofibers and interact with entactin, which binds to collagens to build the ECM. In addition to destabilized sarcolemma in laminin-deficient muscle, mitochondrial apoptosis appears to contribute substantially to disease progression in MDCA1. Detachment of cell membrane from the ECM induces a particular form of apoptotic pathway called anoikis. Inhibition of muscle cell death by transgenic overexpression of the antiapoptosis protein Bcl-2, or through targeted ablation of the pro-apoptosis protein Bax in Lama2−/− mice, alleviated the dystrophic phenotype and extended lifespan of these animals severalfold (Girgenrath et al., 2004). Therefore antiapoptosis therapies could potentially benefit MDCA1 and likely other neuromuscular disorders where apoptosis plays an important role in disease pathogenesis, such as those that result from defective collagen VI. Different types of mutations in three genes (COL6A1, COL6A2, and COL6A3) encoding the subunits of collagen VI cause two clinically distinct myopathies: Ullrich CMD and Bethlem myopathy (Bönnemann, 2011).
Impaired cell signaling at the sarcolemma.
The intracellular module of the DAPC that includes α-dystrobrevin, syntrophins, and neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) regulates the signal transduction cascade at the sarcolemma. The nNOS enzyme produces nitric oxide (NO) from l-arginine, which in turn induces guanylyl cyclase to synthesize cyclic GMP, a signaling molecule broken down by cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterases (PDEs). cGMP functions as a potent vasodilator by inhibiting the vasoconstrictor response to α-adrenergic receptor activation. Muscle contractions activate nNOS and the resultant NO augments local blood flow to meet the increased energy demand of contracting muscle (Kobzik et al., 1994). nNOS is anchored to the sarcolemma via the PDZ domain of the adaptor protein syntrophin, which binds directly to the C-terminal domain of dystrophin. To ensure rapid diffusion of NO to blood vessels, sarcolemmal localization of nNOS is essential for its function as a vasodilator in skeletal muscle. Complete loss of dystrophin dissociates nNOS from the sarcolemma (Brenman et al., 1995), causing functional ischemia and exercise-induced fatigue in DMD patients (Sander et al., 2000). Interestingly, a recent study demonstrated that not only the DMD muscle, but muscles from other types of muscular dystrophies, including those that do not directly involve the DAPC, tend to lose nNOS from the sarcolemma, which implies that many muscular dystrophies may share common mechanisms of exercise-induced fatigue (Kobayashi et al., 2008). Furthermore, using nNOS-null mice, this study demonstrated that exercise-induced fatigue as a result of nNOS loss is distinct from general muscle weakness pertinent to muscle wasting diseases. Treatment of the mdx and Sgca−/− mice, which lack α-sarcoglycan, with the phosphodiesterase 5A inhibitor sildenafil citrate to boost cGMP signaling significantly improved vasodilation and reduced exercise-induced fatigue, which supports the therapeutic benefits of vasomodulation in muscular dystrophies (Kobayashi et al., 2008). Furthermore, syntrophins also bind the dystrophin-related protein α-dystrobrevin, which in turn interacts with dystrophin as well as with sarcoglycans. Mice null for α-dystrobrevin exhibit muscular dystrophy and cardiomyopathy, not because of disruption of the DAPC and sarcolemma but as a result of compromised signaling at the sarcolemma (Grady et al., 1999). In muscle from these mice, nNOS is dislocated from the DAPC and the production of NO is reduced, leading to muscle and heart abnormalities. Recent studies demonstrate that nNOS can also bind directly to the dystrophin protein via a 10–amino acid fragment within spectrin-like repeat 17 (Lai et al., 2009, 2013). In fact, direct interaction with dystrophin appears to be critical for the recruitment of nNOS to the sarcolemma. Although minidystrophin, a truncated version of dystrophin without these specific spectrin-like repeats engineered for antiviral gene therapy, reverses dystrophic pathology in the mdx mouse, it is unable to reduce exercise-induced fatigue; therefore, inclusion of spectrin-like repeats required for nNOS interaction with minidystrophin should be considered in gene replacement therapies. In conclusion, these studies underscore the importance of nNOS signaling in the functioning and maintenance of skeletal muscle.
Cytoskeletal defects in muscular dystrophy.
The main intracellular cytoskeletal component that transmits the mechanical force through the DAPC to ECM is the microfilament network consisting of F-actin (Ervasti and Campbell, 1993; Rybakova et al., 2000). The N-terminal actin-binding domain and spectrin-like repeats within the rod domain of dystrophin bind to actin filaments. However, several recent studies revealed that dystrophin interacts with the other two elements of the cytoskeleton; intermediate filaments (IFs) and microtubules. Multiple members of the IF network are expressed in striated muscle; among these desmin is the predominantly expressed IF protein in myofibers. Desmin connects Z-disks of neighboring myofibrils and anchors myofibrils to intracellular organelles, such as mitochondria and the nucleus, and to the sarcolemma, to maintain a spatial organization between myofibrils and other structural components of the myofiber. Mutations in desmin are associated with the autosomal dominant LGMD1D with dilated cardiomyopathy, with characteristic desmin-positive protein aggregates within the sarcoplasma (Greenberg et al., 2012). The linkage between desmin and the DAPC appears to be mediated by the giant cytolinker protein plectin, mutations in which also underlie muscular dystrophy with skin blistering (epidermolysis bullosa simplex; Smith et al., 1996). Plectin is expressed as multiple isoforms through alternative splicing of its variable N-terminal domain. The C-terminal domain of plectin-1f isoform binds desmin while the actin-binding and plakin domains bind dystrophin and β-dystroglycan at costameres, respectively (Rezniczek et al., 2007). A homozygous 9bp deletion mutation in the first plectin-1f isoform-encoding exon of PLEC was identified in progressive LGMD2Q without skin manifestation, demonstrating a unique role of plectin isoform 1f in skeletal muscle function (Gundesli et al., 2010). Enlarged distance between the sarcolemma and myofibrils and misaligned Z lines in patient muscles suggest that lack of this particular isoform fails to hold these structures together. Other cytolinker proteins such as syncoilin and synemin are expressed in skeletal muscle and have been suggested to mediate interaction of the desmin IF cytoskeleton network with the DAPC (Bellin et al., 2001; Poon et al., 2002). Furthermore, dystrophin directly interacts and stabilizes the organization of the third component of the cellular cytoskeleton—microtubules (Prins et al., 2009)—and microtubule disorganization has been proposed to contribute to disease pathogenesis in DMD. Brief stretching of muscle from mdx mice induces microtubule-dependent activation of NADPH oxidase, which in turn produces reactive oxygen species and increases sarcolemmal Ca+2 influx (Khairallah et al., 2012). Collectively, in contrast to the initial assumption that the F-actin is the only cytoskeletal element interacting with the DAPC, it is now well established that IFs as well as microtubules interact with the DAPC.
Defective sarcolemma repair.
Frequent mechanical stress and the large size of individual muscle fibers render the fragile sarcolemma susceptible to microinjuries. In healthy muscle these contraction-induced membrane injuries are efficiently resealed by a Ca2+-dependent repair pathway. The dynamic repair process performed by fusion of membrane-bound intracellular vesicles with the sarcolemma is orchestrated by intricate interactions between multiple proteins residing both on the sarcolemma and on these vesicles (Fig. 2 A). In contrast to myofiber degeneration that results from loss of connection between the cytoskeleton and the ECM, muscle degeneration can also arise from inefficient repair of naturally damaged sarcolemma. Dysferlin, a 230-kD transmembrane protein with six intracellular C2 domains, is a key component of the Ca2+-dependent sarcolemma repair pathway. It promotes the fusion of the intracellular vesicles with each other and with the sarcolemma at the injury site. Loss-of-function mutations in DYSF underlie three clinically distinct muscular dystrophies, collectively called dysferlinopathies: LGMD2B, Miyoshi myopathy, and distal anterior compartment myopathy (DACM; Bashir et al., 1998; Liu et al., 1998). Miyoshi myopathy prominently affects distal limb muscles, whereas LGMD2B is a proximal muscle disease. Interestingly, identical mutations in DYSF have been associated with both types (Weiler et al., 1999). Dysf−/− mice develop progressive muscular dystrophy, with intact DAPC, which indicates that loss of dysferlin does not destabilize the DAPC (Bansal et al., 2003). Because the intracellular vesicles fail to fuse with the damaged sarcolemma, there is a characteristic accumulation of subsarcolemmal vesicles in dysferlin-deficient muscle.
Dysferlin interacts with multiple proteins. Among these proteins, caveolin-3 (Matsuda et al., 2001) is the principle constituent of plasma membrane caveolae, small invaginations of the plasma membrane that are responsible for LGMD1C when mutated (Minetti et al., 1998). Mitsugumin 53 (MG53), a muscle-specific TRIM (Tri-partite motif) family protein encoded by the TRIM72 gene, is another important member of the sarcolemma membrane repair pathway. Although no mutations in TRIM72 have yet been identified in human muscular dystrophy, MG53 knockout mice develop progressive muscle degeneration, which was demonstrated to result from defective membrane repair (Cai et al., 2009a). Influx of oxidized extracellular environment through damaged sarcolemma into the sarcoplasma appears to oligomerize MG53 residing on intracellular vesicles, which in turn induces their translocation to and nucleation at the acute injury site. Subsequently, through functional interaction with MG53 and caveolin-3, dysferlin facilitates rapid membrane patch formation in the presence of elevated Ca2+ level, and disruption of one of these components can affect the localization and function of the other components (Cai et al., 2009b). Dysferlin also interacts with annexins A1 and A2 (Lennon et al., 2003). Annexins are a family of proteins that bind phospholipids in a Ca2+-dependent manner to assemble a docking platform for interacting proteins at the membrane. A recent study using high-resolution in vivo imaging in zebrafish demonstrated that after membrane injury, cytoplasmic annexin A6 accumulates at the membrane lesion, independently and simultaneously with dysferlin-docked intracellular vesicles, and then together with dysferlin sequentially recruit annexins A2 and A1 to the membrane repair site (Roostalu and Strähle, 2012; Fig. 2 A). In dysferlin-deficient muscles, the localization and distribution of annexin A1 and A2 at the sarcolemma is perturbed (Lennon et al., 2003). In conclusion, sarcolemmal repair involves sequential interaction between multiple proteins, and these proteins could be strong candidates for muscular dystrophies that have not yet been associated with a genetic mutation. Furthermore, variation within these proteins might also modulate phenotypic variability of dysferlin-associated muscle diseases.
Anoctamins are a family of transmembrane proteins with Ca2+-activated chloride channel activity (Tian et al., 2012). Loss-of-function mutations in ANO5, encoding anoctamin 5, were identified in families with LGMD2L and distal nondysferlin Miyoshi myopathy 3 (MMD3; Bolduc et al., 2010). Muscles from subjects with ANO5 mutations displayed multifocal sarcolemma lesions, but unlike in typical dysferlinopathies no subsarcolemmal vesicle accumulation was observed. However, fibroblasts from one MMD3 subject did show impaired membrane repair when the cell membrane was injured in vitro. The function of anoctamin 5 in skeletal muscle still remains unclear. Progressive loss of both proximal as well as distal muscles in different individuals, defective membrane repair in one subject, and predicted Ca2+-activated chloride channel activity point to its potential role in sarcolemma repair, likely through the dysferlin-dependent repair pathway described above. According to the proposed model, increased Ca2+ concentration within a damaged myofiber might activate the putative chloride ion channel ANO5 residing on intracellular vesicles and allow chloride transport into the vesicles to modify their conformation and facilitate recruitment to the injury site (Bolduc et al., 2010).
Disintegration of muscle sarcomeres.
The assembly and maintenance of myofibrils is regulated by multiple proteins that interact with the primary sarcomeric proteins actin and myosin (Fig. 1 B). Mutations in proteins expressed in sarcomeres have been associated with neuromuscular disorders, including several LGMDs, but mutations in sarcomeric proteins are more common in cardiomyopathies. Associated genes and molecular mechanisms of inherited cardiomyopathies are discussed in two recent reviews (Harvey and Leinwand, 2011; McNally et al., 2013). Interestingly, mutations in sarcomeric proteins causative of muscular dystrophy tend to affect distal muscles, i.e., those in hands, forearms, lower legs, and feet. The myotilin protein cross-links α-actinin, filamin-C, and F-actin, and promotes myofibrillogenesis at Z-disks (Salmikangas et al., 2003). Mutations in the MYOT gene were identified in families with LGMD1A (Hauser et al., 2000). Dominant mutations in the actin-binding domain of filamin-C that increase its binding affinity for actin have recently been associated with a distal myopathy (Duff et al., 2011). Nebulin spans the length of the thin filament interacting with its components actin, tropomyosin, tropomodulin, and CAPZ. It regulates the filament length by stabilizing and preventing actin depolymerization (Pappas et al., 2010). Mutations in nebulin are responsible for nemaline myopathy, a group of congenital muscle disorders characterized by generalized muscle weakness and rod-like nemaline bodies in myofibers (Wallgren-Pettersson et al., 2011). Titin extends from the opposing Z-disks of a sarcomere and overlaps in the middle of the sarcomere and is thought to serve as the molecular ruler that controls the length of sarcomere during contraction and relaxation. Mutations in titin have been associated with both muscular dystrophy and cardiomyopathy. Heterozygous mutations in the C-terminal domain of titin, located within the M-line of sarcomeres, cause the late-onset tibial muscular dystrophy, whereas homozygous mutations underlie the more severe LGMD2J (Hackman et al., 2002). Titin mutations associated with dilated cardiomyopathy are, however, overrepresented in its A-band region but are absent in the Z-disk and M-line regions (Herman et al., 2012). Furthermore, mutations in titin lead to secondary reduction of calpain 3, a muscle-specific, calcium-dependent protease that is mutated in LGMD2A (Richard et al., 1995). LGMD2G is associated with mutations in telethonin (titin-cap), which anchors two parallel titin molecules within a single sarcomere to the Z-disk (Moreira et al., 2000). Given the complexity of the organization and biogenesis of sarcomeres, mutations in many of the interacting proteins have been associated with several forms of muscular dystrophies. These disorders have been reviewed recently (Udd, 2009).
Toxic RNA induced muscle degeneration.
Unlike the majority of muscular dystrophies caused by mutations that alter the amino acid sequence, the primary cause of myotonic dystrophy (DM) is the accumulation of toxic RNA in cell nucleus. Myotonic dystrophy type 1 (DM1) is caused by a CTG trinucleotide repeat expansion (from 50 to >2,000) within the 3′ UTR of the dystrophia myotonica protein kinase (DMPK) gene (Brook et al., 1992; Fu et al., 1992; Mahadevan et al., 1992). DM1 is a multisystem disease that predominantly affects skeletal muscles and the central nervous system, and it is also considered the most common adult onset muscular dystrophy, with a prevalence of ∼1/8,000. It is characterized by myotonia (slow relaxation of the muscles after contraction), muscle degeneration, cataracts, cardiac arrhythmias, and cognitive impairment. The less frequent DM2 results from a CCTG repeat expansion (from 75 to >10,000) in intron 1 of the CCHC-type zinc finger nucleic acid binding protein (CNBP; Liquori et al., 2001). The mRNA products transcribed from the expanded alleles of these genes are retained within the nucleus, forming punctuated foci of RNP aggregates (Taneja et al., 1995; Davis et al., 1997; Mankodi et al., 2003). In both types of DM, mis-splicing of downstream target gene transcripts secondary to these repeat sequence amplifications underlie the molecular etiology of the disease. Muscleblind-like proteins (MBNL) are a highly conserved, developmentally regulated family of proteins that regulate alternative splicing of a large number of pre-mRNAs. The native cognate binding site of MBNL1 includes a CUG motif. Therefore, MBNL1 binds to expanded CUG and CCUG repeats of the DMPK1 and CNBP mRNAs, respectively, and becomes sequestered within the nucleus (Miller et al., 2000; Mankodi et al., 2001; Fig. 3 A). Sequestration of MBNL1 depletes its cellular abundance, which in turn leads to inappropriate splicing of many pre-mRNAs that depend on MBNL1 for their transition from an embryonic to postnatal splicing pattern (Lin et al., 2006). Two of the well-studied pre-mRNAs that are prominently affected and directly contribute to disease symptoms encode muscle-specific chloride channel, responsible for the hyperexcitability of muscle (myotonia; Charlet-B et al., 2002), and insulin receptor, which explains insulin resistance in DM patients (Savkur et al., 2001). Mouse models expressing CTG repeats from the 3′ UTR of the human skeletal α-actin transgene (HASLR; Mankodi et al., 2000) and null for muscleblind-like 1 (Mbnl1ΔE3/ΔE3; Kanadia et al., 2003) reproduce several human phenotypes including embryonic pattern of pre-mRNA splicing in adult tissues. Genome-wide gene expression and pre-mRNA splicing analyses in these two mouse models revealed >200 exons with altered splicing profiles (Du et al., 2010). More than 80% of the splicing differences observed in HASLR muscles were also seen in Mbnl1-deficient muscles, which suggests that loss of Mbnl1 likely accounts for the majority of abnormal splicing occurring in DM. Furthermore, expression levels of genes encoding the ECM proteins were overrepresented among the altered transcripts, highlighting common molecular defects with other types of muscular dystrophies. These genome-wide studies of mRNA expression and splicing events have identified potential candidate genes that might contribute to disease symptoms when inappropriately spliced. The specific roles of individual target genes in disease etiology remain to be established. In addition to MBNL1 depletion, expanded CUG repeats induce aberrant activation of PKC, which in turn phosphorylates and increases the activity of a second splicing regulatory factor CUGBP Elav like family 1 (CELF1), formerly called as CUGPB1 (Roberts et al., 1997; Philips et al., 1998; Kuyumcu-Martinez et al., 2007; Fig. 3 A). MBNL1 and CELF1 are thought to act as antagonistic splicing regulatory factors. CELF1 is also known to control mRNA translation and stability. Consequently, imbalance between these two genomic regulatory factors has a widespread effect on a large number of genes that result in systemic disease.
Ectopic expression of a toxic transcription factor.
Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is an unusual and the third most common muscular dystrophy, characterized by the asymmetric and progressive weakness and atrophy of skeletal muscles of the face, scapula, and upper arms, frequently accompanied by retinal telangiectasia and/or hearing loss. The common form of FSHD, type 1, is caused by contractions of tandemly arrayed repeat elements of 3.3 kb within the highly polymorphic macrosatellite element D4Z4 on the distal end of chromosome 4q35 (Wijmenga et al., 1992; van Deutekom et al., 1993). FSHD1 is, however, associated with D4Z4 mutations that arise only on the permissive chromosomal allele 4qA, whereas deletions on the equally common allele in the general population 4qB do not present any pathogenic consequences (Lemmers et al., 2002). In unaffected individuals, the D4Z4 array usually consists of 11–100 repeats, whereas FSHD1 patients carry 1–10 repeats. Furthermore, each repeat unit of D4Z4 contains an open reading frame encoding the transcription factor double homeobox 4 (DUX4). Reduction of the D4Z4 size to a pathogenic threshold of <10 repeats relaxes the chromatin state within D4Z4 and induces the expression of the otherwise presumably repressed DUX4 retrogene. The expression of DUX4 embedded in the last repeat extends into the adjacent pLAM sequence, which contains a polymorphic canonical polyadenylation signal. Transcripts expressed from the permissive allele (4qA) are polyadenylated and stabilized, consequently producing protein, whereas the nonpolyadenylated transcripts transcribed from the nonpermissive allele (4qB) are degraded (Lemmers et al., 2010). The double homeobox domain containing transcription factor DUX4 in turn induces muscle cell death (Kowaljow et al., 2007; Snider et al., 2010; Fig. 3 B). The exact mechanisms of its toxicity to muscle cells are not clear yet. Furthermore, DUX4 is spliced into two isoforms, the full-length protein (DUX4-fl), which was shown to be expressed exclusively in ∼1/1,000 cultured FSHD myoblasts, causing cell death shortly after translation, and a shorter nontoxic isoform expressed in both affected and unaffected cells and muscles (Snider et al., 2010).
Later findings challenged the notion that the expression of DUX4 is restricted to affected cells and muscles, by demonstrating that DUX4-fl is also expressed in unaffected cells and muscles, albeit at lower frequency, which is suggestive of potential disease modifiers (Jones et al., 2012). DUX4-fl was shown to induce a large number of genes that are normally expressed in stem cells and germline (Geng et al., 2012). However, the significance of these genes in disease pathogenesis is elusive. Strikingly, injection of very low amounts of DUX4-fl mRNA into zebrafish embryos recapitulated several human phenotypes, including the extramuscular phenotypes such as eye and ear abnormalities and asymmetric involvement of affected organs (Mitsuhashi et al., 2013).
The less common type, FSHD2, which is clinically indistinguishable from FSHD1, was previously linked to hypomethylation of D4Z4 chromatin (van Overveld et al., 2003). However, the genetic determinant of this phenomenon was not known until recently. Whole-exome sequencing in FSHD2 families identified heterozygous mutations in the SMCHD1 gene that co-segregate with D4Z4 hypomethylation of the permissive allele in affected family members (Lemmers et al., 2012). This study demonstrated that in addition to the haploinsufficiency of SMCHD1, inheritance of the polyadenylated DUX4 is required for disease manifestation. Consequently, these findings converge the underlying disease mechanisms of FSHD1 and FSHD2. SMCHD1 encodes for the SMCHD1 (structural maintenance of chromosomes flexible hinge domain containing 1) protein and is required for maintenance of the genome-wide hypermethylation of D4Z4, and likely other repeat elements. It has yet to be tested whether genetic variants in SMCHD1 also modify the disease phenotype of FSHD1, such as the highly variable age of onset, mutation penetrance, and extramuscular involvement.
Remarkable progress has been made over the last two decades toward deciphering the cellular and molecular underpinnings of neuromuscular disorders. Better understanding of the molecular mechanisms has paved the way for the development of targeted therapeutic interventions for several muscular dystrophies, not only specific for each type of disease, but also specific for individuals with certain mutations. Progress in antisense oligonucleotide-mediated exon skipping to restore the open reading frame of mutated dystrophin or nonsense mutation read-through approaches developed to treat DMD has already started showing encouraging outcomes in clinical trials. Furthermore, recent advances in improved diagnostics, in particular using next-generation sequencing technologies, now allow the rapid (literally within hours) screening of newborns for potentially pathogenic genetic lesions. Early identification of mutations causative of muscular dystrophies will enable clinicians to take proactive measures to halt or reverse muscle degeneration.
The work in our laboratory is supported by the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development grant (5U54HD060848) to the Senator Paul D. Wellstone Muscular Dystrophy Cooperative Research Center for FSHD, by research (MDA177911) and development (MDA202863) grants from the Muscular Dystrophy Association, and by a grant from the Bernard F. and Alva B. Gimbel Foundation.
We apologize to our colleagues whose work we could not cite because of space limitations.
congenital muscular dystrophy
dystrophin-associated protein complex
Duchenne muscular dystrophy
facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy
limb-girdle muscular dystrophy
neuronal nitric oxide synthase