Secreted Wnt ligands appear to activate a variety of signaling pathways. Two papers in this issue now present genetic evidence that “noncanonical” Wnt signaling inhibits the “canonical” Wnt/β-catenin pathway. Westfall et al. (2003a) show that zebrafish embryos lacking maternal Wnt-5 function are dorsalized due to ectopic activation of β-catenin, whereas Topol et al. (2003) report that chondrogenesis in the distal mouse limb bud depends on inhibition of Wnt/β-catenin signaling by a paralogue of Wnt-5. These studies present the first genetic confirmation of the previous hypothesis that vertebrate Wnt signaling pathways can act in an antagonistic manner.

Wnt signaling regulates differentiation and proliferation of a variety of cell types during animal development and is also implicated in tumor formation. Some Wnts activate a signaling pathway that results in increased levels of β-catenin, which in turn modulates transcription of target genes (Huelsken and Behrens, 2002). The earliest function of this so-called “canonical” Wnt/β-catenin pathway in vertebrate embryogenesis is to specify dorsal cell fates. Consequently, overexpression of some Wnts (such as Wnt-8) in early zebrafish and Xenopus embryos promotes formation of excess dorsal cells at the expense of ventral cell fates. In contrast, overexpression of other Wnts (including Wnt-5 and Wnt-11) interferes with gastrulation movements rather than modulating β-catenin or cell fates (Torres et al., 1996). Genetic evidence for the existence of such “noncanonical” Wnt signaling in vertebrates has been provided by analysis of zebrafish Wnt-11 mutations, which cause defects in gastrulation movements that cannot be rescued by β-catenin (Heisenberg et al., 2000; Tada et al., 2002).

Intriguingly, for many years there has been evidence that the biological activities of some Wnts might work in an opposing manner. For example, overexpression of a Wnt-5 paralogue blocks the ability of Wnt-8 to promote dorsal cell fate in Xenopus (Torres et al., 1996), and overexpression of Wnt-5 can activate the nemo-like kinase, which in C. elegans and mammalian cells inhibits Tcf transcription factors to which β-catenin binds to regulate gene expression (Ishitani et al., 2003). However, there has so far been no genetic evidence supporting the apparent antagonism of some Wnts in vertebrates.

The laboratories of Diane Slusarski and Yingzi Yang now present this genetic evidence (Fig. 1) (Westfall et al., 2003a; Topol et al., 2003). Slusarski's laboratory shows that removal of both the maternal and zygotic function of zebrafish Wnt-5 (MZWnt-5) not only enhances the morphogenesis defects of zygotic Wnt-5 mutants, but also results in variable degrees of dorsalization, including formation of a secondary axis (Westfall et al., 2003a). These phenotypes resemble those obtained by overactivation of Wnt/β-catenin signaling, and indeed the authors find ectopic stabilization of β-catenin and ectopic expression of β-catenin target genes in MZWnt-5 mutant embryos. These findings add strong genetic support to the previously suggested requirement of a Wnt signal for development of ventral cell fates and antagonism of dorsal fates, as has been proposed based on the ability of dominant–negative forms of Wnt-11 and of a frizzled receptor to interfere with ventral cell fates in Xenopus (Itoh and Sokol, 1999; Kühl et al., 2000a). Similarly, Yang's laboratory shows that in the distal tip of mouse limb buds Wnt-5a antagonizes Wnt/β-catenin signaling, since in Wnt-5a/ limbs higher levels of β-catenin can be detected in the distal tip where a β-catenin–responsive reporter is ectopically expressed (Topol et al., 2003). Chondrocyte differentiation, which is defective in the Wnt-5a/ limbs, can be partially restored by transplantation of cells expressing a secreted Wnt inhibitor, which presumably interferes with canonical Wnts only. Thus, in the mouse limb bud, Wnt-5a signaling appears to promote chondrocyte differentiation by antagonizing the Wnt/β-catenin pathway.

Which signaling pathway(s) do Wnt-5 paralogues activate to inhibit Wnt/β-catenin signaling? Noncanonical Wnts have been reported to be able to activate a wide variety of cellular responses upon overexpression in vertebrate embryos or cultured mammalian cells. In some cellular contexts, Wnt-5 paralogues activate the Wnt/Ca2+ pathway, which involves Ca2+ release from intracellular stores, stimulation of protein kinase C (PKC), the Ca2+/calmodulin–dependent kinase CamKII, and the Ca2+-dependent transcription factor NFAT (Kühl et al., 2000b; Saneyoshi et al., 2002). Wnt-5 paralogues might also modulate a vertebrate counterpart to the Drosophila planar cell polarity (PCP) pathway (Tada et al., 2002; Mlodzik, 2002).

Wnt/Ca2+ signaling has previously been implicated in specification of ventral cell fates in Xenopus, since both a dominant–negative Wnt-11 (thought to interfere with noncanonical Wnts) and a dominant–negative CamKII promote dorsal cell fates (Kühl et al., 2000a). In addition, interference with the phosphatidylinositol (PI) cycle—an important signaling pathway that leads to intracellular Ca2+ release—likewise dorsalizes Xenopus and zebrafish embryos (Kume et al., 1997; Westfall et al., 2003b). However, there has been no genetic evidence supporting these observations. Westfall et al. (2003a) now show that zygotic zebrafish Wnt-5 mutant embryos have slightly reduced Ca2+ fluxes at early stages and that a constitutively active CamKII can partially rescue the morphogenesis defects of such mutants. In addition, lower doses of PI cycle inhibitors can phenocopy the morphogenesis defects of zygotic Wnt-5 mutants. These results indicate that Wnt-5 may indeed be required for calcium signaling and might regulate gastrulation movements via the Wnt/Ca2+ pathway. However, a growing body of evidence also suggests that PCP signaling is required for gastrulation movements (Tada et al., 2002), and at present it is unclear whether these pathways act in parallel or overlap.

The papers by Westfall et al. (2003a) and Topol et al. (2003) also raise a number of questions. Although both groups show that Wnt-5 paralogues are required as repressors of β-catenin signaling, it is not clear if this is through Ca2+ signaling or by something else activated by Wnt-5. Thus, further research will be needed to elucidate the signaling pathway used by Wnt-5 to antagonize Wnt/β-catenin by rescue and genetic interaction experiments in MZWnt-5 zebrafish embryos, as well as determining Ca2+ flux in these embryos. Moreover, Topol et al. (2003) provide evidence that the inhibition of β-catenin they see is not mediated by activation of CamKII, PKC, NFAT, or c-jun NH2-terminal kinase (JNK). Therefore, currently described effectors of Wnt/Ca2+ signaling do not appear to adequately explain the inhibitory effect of Wnt-5 on β-catenin signaling in cultured mammalian cells. Topol et al. (2003) go on to show that Siah2, a component of a known β-catenin destruction complex, is transcriptionally activated by Wnt-5a, concomitant with observed decreases in β-catenin levels. Given the paucity of information on how Wnt signaling might regulate gene expression in a β-catenin–independent manner, it will be interesting to study how Siah2 is regulated.

Another question regards the relevance of these findings to cancer biology, given that activation of β-catenin function is observed in many cancers. The finding of Topol et al. (2003) that Wnt-5a inhibits β-catenin levels and transcriptional activity in a colon cancer cell line adds to the sporadic literature suggesting that this Wnt might be involved in some cancers.

Although our understanding of noncanonical Wnt signaling lags far behind our knowledge of the Wnt/β-catenin pathway, the papers of Westfall et al. (2003a) and Topol et al. (2003) make valuable contributions to understanding the involvement of noncanonical Wnt signaling in promoting ventral cell fates in embryos, and chondrogenesis, respectively. Both papers also provide the first genetic hint that distinct vertebrate Wnt signaling pathways may indeed be capable of cross-talk, leading to functional antagonism.

Heisenberg, C.P., M. Tada, G.J. Rauch, L. Saude, M.L. Concha, R. Geisler, D.L. Stemple, J.C. Smith, and S.W. Wilson.
. Silberblick/Wnt11 mediates convergent extension movements during zebrafish gastrulation.
Huelsken, J., and J. Behrens.
. The Wnt signalling pathway.
J. Cell Sci.
Ishitani, T., S. Kishida, J. Hyodo-Miura, N. Ueno, J. Yasuda, M. Waterman, H. Shibuya, R.T. Moon, J. Ninomiya-Tsuji, and K. Matsumoto.
. The TAK1-NLK mitogen-activated protein kinase cascade functions in the Wnt-5a/Ca2+ pathway to antagonize Wnt/beta-catenin signaling.
Mol. Cell. Biol.
Itoh, K., and S.Y. Sokol.
. Axis determination by inhibition of Wnt signaling in Xenopus.
Genes Dev.
Kühl, M., L.C. Sheldahl, C.C. Malbon, and R.T. Moon.
a. Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II is stimulated by Wnt and Frizzled homologs and promotes ventral cell fates in Xenopus.
J. Biol. Chem.
Kühl, M., L.C. Sheldahl, M. Park, J.R. Miller, and R.T. Moon.
b. The Wnt/Ca2+ pathway: a new vertebrate Wnt signaling pathway takes shape.
Trends Genet.
Kume, S., A. Muto, T. Inoue, K. Suga, H. Okano, and K. Mikoshiba.
. Role of inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate receptor in ventral signaling in Xenopus embryos.
Mlodzik, M.
. Planar cell polarization: do the same mechanisms regulate Drosophila tissue polarity and vertebrate gastrulation?
Trends Genet.
Saneyoshi, T., S. Kume, Y. Amasaki, and K. Mikoshiba.
. The Wnt/calcium pathway activates NF-AT and promotes ventral cell fate in Xenopus embryos.
Tada, M., M.L. Concha, and C.P. Heisenberg.
. Non-canonical Wnt signalling and regulation of gastrulation movements.
Semin. Cell Dev. Biol.
Topol, L., X. Jiang, H. Choi, L. Garrett-Beal, P.J. Carolan, and Y. Yang.
. Wnt-5a inhibits the canonical Wnt pathway by promoting GSK-3 independent β-catenin degradation.
J. Cell Biol.
Torres, M.A., J.A. Yang-Snyder, S.M. Purcell, A.A. DeMarais, L.L. McGrew, and R.T. Moon.
. Activities of the Wnt-1 class of secreted signaling factors are antagonized by the Wnt-5A class and by a dominant negative cadherin in early Xenopus development.
J. Cell Biol.
Westfall, T.A., B. Hjertos, J. Twedt, R. Brimeyer, J. Gladon, A. Olberding, M. Furutani-Seiki, and D.C. Slusarski.
a. Wnt-5/pipetail functions in vertebrate axis formation as a negative regulator of Wnt/β-catenin activity.
J. Cell Biol.
Westfall, T.A., B. Hjertos, and D.C. Slusarski.
b. Requirement for intracellular calcium modulation in zebrafish dorsal-ventral patterning.
Dev. Biol.

Abbreviations used in this paper: JNK, c-jun NH2-terminal kinase; PCP, planar cell polarity; PI, phosphatidylinositol; PKC, protein kinase C.